News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by ZanyProgrammer on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @11:09AM (#10010283)
I bet the response from a lot of mainstream American leftists will be: whatever the union does is fine, because by definition unions are supposed to support their members.
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by danielweber on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @11:55AM (#10010672)
Unions are supposed to support their members, and legally defend them. If it wasn't the union making this crazy request, it would be the cops' lawyers.

And that's not a bad thing. Proper legal defense is an extremely important and fundamental right, even for the people we dislike. Adequate legal defense is often how people end up needing to protect themselves from crooked cops.

If this crazy request is honored, then something is broke.

Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by nkurz on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:33PM (#10010956)
There is a difference between supporting any illegal action committed by individual union members, and supporting the interests of the members as a whole. I'd think (hope?) that there is a degree of egregiousness where the union would realize that they are hurting the group as a whole by defending the corrupt individuals. By contrast, the defendants' lawyers are allowed to concern themselves only with their clients.
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by logfromblammo on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @01:28PM (#10011358)
Unions are supposed to act in accord with their own charters or constitutions. Unions are supposed to support the interests of their entire membership. The union could have, upon watching the video, expelled the cops seen in it for gross and egregious violations of the union's standards of professional conduct. The former members would still be able to use the collectively negotiated clauses in their contracts that protect them from unjust disciplinary actions.

If the union does not have standards of professional conduct that would allow them to expel a cop for blatant, open, and notorious destruction of private property, unlawful conversion, spoliation of evidence, deprivation of rights under color of law, and grossly unprofessional and unethical conduct, why the heck would any county or municipality hire any of their members?

Most unions can kick you out when shown good cause, including for actions that are neither illegal nor unethical, such as joining a competing union.

This is probably something the union should have backed away from, as it makes their entire membership look like they support corruption in policing.

Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by danielweber on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @03:34PM (#10012255)
and supporting the interests of the members as a whole

That is even more frightening. The union already has tremendous opportunity to negotiate for the rights of some members by giving up on the rights of other members. If it could pick and choose which cases were "really worth it" it would end up defending organizational insiders while declining to defend Joe Sixpack.

One positive thing unions provide is that they provide a valuable way for workers to know about and exercise their legal rights. If different kind of organization were providing that benefit, it woulLd still be defending workers accused of bad things.

"Even those accused of REALLY bad things?"

Especially those accused of really bad thing

Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by logfromblammo on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @05:41PM (#10013065)
You are making this out to be an accusation, when it is, in fact, a public release of damning evidence.

There is no dispute that the cops in the video did what they were recorded in doing. The argument is literally that the prosecutors should not consider the publicly available evidence when determining whether the cops should be charged with a crime.

The union is not bound by the state's rules of evidence. It can make an independent assessment of the facts available to it and decide whether the union would be better served by keeping those guys in it and defending them to the last, or by cutting them loose and preserving its reputation for the remaining members.

It is all down to the operating principles ensconced in its own articles of organization.

What goes beyond the pale? If Joe Sixpack sat down and ate a live baby, feet first, and it was caught on video, which then went viral on YouTube, would the union still go to bat for him?

Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by jMyles on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:53PM (#10011094)
The difference is that we, as the taxpaying public, have no choice but to fund this organization (the "union") because our civic entity (the police force) is obliged to hire only from among its membership.

I don't care what these cops or their privately-funded lawyers say.

But I do care that I have to fund this idiocy.

Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by eevilspock on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @11:13AM (#10010331)
You oversimplify leftists in the same way some leftists oversimplify anti-union sentiment.
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by mikeash on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @11:42AM (#10010571)
I don't think I have ever seen anyone express that sentiment except to ridicule it, as you have here. And at least in my section of the community, "leftism" is so common that it's assumed to be the default.
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by nkurz on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:39PM (#10010995)
It's interesting to note that Dan Weber appears to feel the 'defend all actions' is obviously correct, while you say your community feels that it is obviously wrong. Presumably he would say the opposite about his community. I don't know either of you, but I wonder if there is less consensus on this issue than either of you believes. Or are you two in fundamentally different communities?
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by mikeash on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:54PM (#10011108)
Who is Dan Weber?

I'm sure we're in different communities, but surely there are a lot of "mainstream leftists" with lots of public visibility? And I haven't seen "unions are always correct" expressed by public figures.

Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by nkurz on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @02:09PM (#10011635)
Sorry, I thought it was clear from context. Dan Weber is 'danielweber', who wrote a sibling comment to yours, but starting from the opposite premise.
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by mikeash on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @02:38PM (#10011828)
I didn't see it, since I didn't revisit the whole thread again.

That comment is rather weird. It seems to be saying basically, "The cops are entitled to a legal defense, therefore a legal defense is good. This is a legal defense, therefore this is good."

But the problem is not really that the union is legally defending these officers (if that is in fact part of their responsibilities then it's only reasonable that they should do so) but that they're doing it crazily. Filing a lawsuit to suppress good evidence from being used in an internal investigation is not a reasonable legal defense in my eyes.

Anyway, I don't know that that comment qualifies as "anything the union does is fine," unless that was actually supposed to be a parody of something less extreme.

Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by RockyMcNuts on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:51PM (#10011076)
A lot of people respond to videos of police malfeasance by blaming the victim who must have been a bad guy and somehow provoked it. Confirmation bias is a powerful thin.
Re:The Chutzpah of a Police Union in Santa Ana, California by elektromekatron on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @01:09PM (#10011227)
Unions are also supposed to kick out members who bring them into disrepute.