Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by tim333 on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @08:00AM
(#10009104)
It's complicated but solar keeps getting cheaper, fossil doesn't. On the other hand solar stops working an night unlike fossil so you need more complicated infrastructure. I just googled the latest price for solar and was slightly amazed it's dropped to 3.87 c/kWh for a bulk deal in Nevada. To put that in perspective I pay about 20 c/kWh as a consumer in London. Solar was much more a couple of years back. I've found an eia.gov estimate that the cost of coal generation including building the plant for 2020 will be about 9.5c/kWh in the US.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @08:44AM
(#10009301)
We don't particularly need a more complex infrastructure, we already have a complex infrastructure to deal with the fact that energy demand is highest during the day and much lower at night. So some plants only operate during the day, pumped storage goes into pump mode at night to release at peak times the next day, people get offered lower rates to use the baseline nuclear power for storage heaters and so on.
With widespread solar that just gets flipped, as the peak solar production maps better to peak usage in most places, so a pumped hydro system might pump water at midday using cheap solar energy, and release the energy in the evening or nightime and "peaker" gas plants would fill in what night-time wind production, nuclear and hydro (depending on the local resource base) can't cover.
This is already starting to happen, you see news stories every so often about prices going negative at peak solar times in various countries. Once it happens often enough that it's no longer headline grabbing, then people can build business cases around using (and/or time-shifting) that cheap energy, just like people did with cheap nuclear power at night.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @10:35AM
(#10009958)
Not so much any more (and getting cheaper), and orbital has huge advantages. You can have square kilometers of collectors in orbit, with no ecological impact statements to file, or eminent domain issues to solve, or annoyed neighbors. You can grow an orbital farm essentially without bound, without buying any expensive real estate. You can beam the energy where its needed instead of having to consume it locally.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:47PM
(#10011047)
Land has to be close to use or transmission losses reduce efficacy. And day/night 50% loss, remember? Feasibility depends upon cost mostly - and that's changing every day.
Also, most solar worldwide is large solar farms. Rooftop is a yuppie gimmick of no significance.
There were under a million private, rooftop solar installations, which are each very likely under 1KW. Which amounts to maybe < 1GW total? Which amounts to a percent of a percent of the solar-farm output. Which fits in the category of 'gimmick' very nicely.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @05:34PM
(#10013023)
From 2013:
"Already, the average size of a rooftop solar system around the country is 3kW – and many of the new systems are well above that. According to Johnston’s data, 5kW systems are now the most popular in the progressive “solar” states such as Queensland and South Australia – while 3kW remains the most popular in NSW and W.A. That is probably a reflection of the tariffs paid for exports to the grid.
Of course, Australia still has some way to go to catch up with the US – where according to SunPower, which specializes in solar leasing products, the average size of rooftop solar systems has gone to 8.3kW.
That’s got something to do with the size of the roofs, and also the tariff measures. Most places in the US get a 1:1 tariff, so the incentive is there to put on a larger system."
It puts residential and distributed commercial (so small installations at businesses and the like) at over 4 gigawatts.
Replying to your edit: ~1 GW of rooftop solar would no longer be a percent of a percent... It is the case that utility scale installations dominate, but rooftop is not insignificant:
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by jerven on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @04:11AM
(#10008479)
In the developing world fuel logistics are a major cost. Local solar+battery is quickly cheaper in the long run in areas where infrastructure is lacking. However, access to capital is a major challenge. i.e. the upfront costs means the cheaper system does not get deployed.
It is quite common that a family could afford 1$ of fuel a month for kerosene lamps, but not the 20$ for a solar charged battery led lamp. As the 20$ even if a great investment after 2 years is out of reach.
Solar starts to make a whole lot of sense if there is no or only a primitive grid to hook into. i.e. compare the boom of mobile phone use in Africa.
A KM of high quality copper wire is not cheap, either. To a central powerplant, distribution of fossil fuel to decentralized power plants is very expensive and very wasteful.
The economically developing world has a great problem in accessing capital, not in investing it usefully.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by __Joker on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @04:24AM
(#10008517)
Upfront cost is a major factor, which I have noticed firsthand while involved in the solar powered backup. It is almost you have to pay 20x for the solar powered back up. It is pretty difficult to convince the people in the developing world to go for solar, where environment factor most of the time is not a cause of concern for the consumer.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by pjc50 on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @05:30AM
(#10008677)
There has been some work on leased panels with built-in microbilling, so the user doesn't have to pay the upfront cost. From a western point of view it's nasty to have a locked down piece of technology that requires you to insert coin to keep it working, but when people have no access to the alternatives it seems more reasonable.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by thebmax on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @09:04AM
(#10009400)
Solar is not reliable without batteries and even with batteries in many parts of US, will not generate sufficient electricity to maintain our current standard of living. Nevada and parts of the south have lots of sun but most northern states will not generate enough power in the winter months. Furthermore this lack of reliability means you also have to build natural gas plants to power up when its cloudy out or at nighttime. This means twice the capital for the same end. When you see those listed prices for solar its for panels installed without batteries and usually in places with lots of sun.
There is also the mess it creates with the grid. The business model of electrical companies is that in your monthly bill you pay for both power and for the grid that delivers it to you. If everyone puts solar on their roof it destroys the business model of the electrical companies and in the occasions where you still want to use grid power (at night, cloudy days etc) your rates will inevitably be higher or someone else has to pay for maintaining the grid and your socializing grid usage.
I think most of the hype around solar is way overdone. Too much solar can really can do lasting damage to an electrical grid and cause massive economic harm. This has happened in Germany where they subsidized renewables so much that they pushed out reliable power from the grid and now they are having the subsidize gas/coal generation so the grid will remain reliable. Furthermore, electricity prices have gone up enormously causing large industrial companies to move abroad or scale back operations. Electricity is the lifeblood of an economy and arbitrarily raising prices and messing with how electricity is delivered and managed can have large unintended consequences especially when decided by politicians who know nothing about the science or business.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @10:32AM
(#10009933)
I'm continually amazed by what Americans can be convinced is the free market at work by vested interests. Wanting to stop politicians messing with the electricity grid is "Keep your government hands off my medicare"-level disconnect from reality.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by thebmax on Friday August 07, 2015 @11:24AM
(#10022966)
I'm continually amazed by people who think government bureaucrats make better decisions than consumers. Or people who think they know whats best for everyone else. You don't think renewable energy companies also hire lobbyists? Are you so sure of yourself that you know what everyone else in the country should use for power?
You're right electricity is heavily regulated and has been for quite some time. Despite the regulation however most companies generally operate as a lowest cost to consumers basis. Consumers ask for the lowest prices and electricity companies tend to oblige.
When politicians decide they very often have some vested interest as a priority and try to raise rates by handing special favors to certain industries.
What makes you think when politicians make decisions based on whats best for consumers vs. whats best for whoever donated to their campaign? If you think renewable energy companies don't hire lobbyists you suffer from a disconnect from reality.
Also, you didn't argue my main point which is solar isn't competitive to other sources. Should everyone pay more for electricity?
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by ZeroGravitas on Saturday August 08, 2015 @02:09AM
(#10026498)
Yes, people should pay more for electricity that is generated by heavily polluting sources like coal and gas, since if they don't pay directly, they pay indirectly for health care etc.
The obvious, standard, free market answer to this (which it seems you'd be in favor of given the political elements of your argument) is some kind of carbon tax. With externalities accounted for wind and solar are the obvious market choices for new generation capacity (and efficiency is rewarded with correct prices too). They're often the best choice now even without this market correction, and continually drop in price to make this more common. That's why we're at some kind of tipping point and the old vested interests realise they're in danger.
(Note in actual implementations of this they often either return the money raised directly to consumers, or cut other taxes to compensate, so you pay more for some things, but still come out aheadahead overall).
You can see Elon Musk sigh every time he mentions this as it's so obviously the right answer, but politically toxic in the US, for no logical reason, despite it being the market friendly, small government answer. A tax specifically designed to phase itself out over time. Instead we've got a strange web of government subsidies and regulations because the democrats like those kind of thing, and the libertarian side of things has been bought off by the vested interests.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by thebmax on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:01PM
(#10055170)
I see your points and agree a carbon tax is the most market friendly way to account for environmental externalities. However, my main point is that wind and solar are NOT economically viable despite what Elon and every other silicon valley expert seems to believe. Even with carbon taxes priced in they can't match the price of natural gas and coal. The reason is that they are not reliable sources of energy and with both of them you need batteries of some other type of storage to smooth out production. This essentially doubles the costs. Everything you read about the 'cost' of solar and wind doesn't take into account storage or the overbuild required to have backup power for cloudy days. The type of grid that uses 100% solar/wind would be a completely unreliable grid and cost considerable more for everyone. Solar and wind aren't being adopted because they are worse for consumers, not because some cabal of special interests are keeping them out.
In fact the opposite is true. The only reason solar is being adopted at all in almost every region in the world is because of government subsidies.
(Source: I build solar and wind farms for a living).
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by seren on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @03:49AM
(#10008437)
I don't necessarily have an enlightened opinion, but when you compare solar vs fossil fuel, most of the time you should compare (solar + battery) vs fuel.
Re:Bright (YC W15) raises $4M to bring solar to the developi...
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @06:00AM
(#10008748)
Their Mexican site seems to target the standard middle-class homeowner with grid connection model. I wonder why they're positioning themselves as off-grid for Africa? I would have thought the same model would be a good place to start.
http://www.pv-magazine.com/news/details/beitrag/buffett-stri...
http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/electricity_generation.cfm
With widespread solar that just gets flipped, as the peak solar production maps better to peak usage in most places, so a pumped hydro system might pump water at midday using cheap solar energy, and release the energy in the evening or nightime and "peaker" gas plants would fill in what night-time wind production, nuclear and hydro (depending on the local resource base) can't cover.
This is already starting to happen, you see news stories every so often about prices going negative at peak solar times in various countries. Once it happens often enough that it's no longer headline grabbing, then people can build business cases around using (and/or time-shifting) that cheap energy, just like people did with cheap nuclear power at night.
Also, most solar worldwide is large solar farms. Rooftop is a yuppie gimmick of no significance.
The Union Of Concerned Scientists seem to disagree with you that its a "yuppie gimmick".
http://www.ucsusa.org/our-work/clean-energy/increase-renewab...
There were under a million private, rooftop solar installations, which are each very likely under 1KW. Which amounts to maybe < 1GW total? Which amounts to a percent of a percent of the solar-farm output. Which fits in the category of 'gimmick' very nicely.
{Edit: math, thanks for pointing it out?}
"Already, the average size of a rooftop solar system around the country is 3kW – and many of the new systems are well above that. According to Johnston’s data, 5kW systems are now the most popular in the progressive “solar” states such as Queensland and South Australia – while 3kW remains the most popular in NSW and W.A. That is probably a reflection of the tariffs paid for exports to the grid.
Of course, Australia still has some way to go to catch up with the US – where according to SunPower, which specializes in solar leasing products, the average size of rooftop solar systems has gone to 8.3kW.
That’s got something to do with the size of the roofs, and also the tariff measures. Most places in the US get a 1:1 tariff, so the incentive is there to put on a larger system."
http://cleantechnica.com/2013/05/28/graph-of-the-day-super-s...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_the_United_Stat...
It puts residential and distributed commercial (so small installations at businesses and the like) at over 4 gigawatts.
Replying to your edit: ~1 GW of rooftop solar would no longer be a percent of a percent... It is the case that utility scale installations dominate, but rooftop is not insignificant:
http://www.seia.org/research-resources/solar-industry-data
(One of the bullet points there is that more than 1 GW of rooftop was installed in 2014)
1 million times 1 KW is a Gigawatt, not one 1 Megawatt.
It is quite common that a family could afford 1$ of fuel a month for kerosene lamps, but not the 20$ for a solar charged battery led lamp. As the 20$ even if a great investment after 2 years is out of reach.
Solar starts to make a whole lot of sense if there is no or only a primitive grid to hook into. i.e. compare the boom of mobile phone use in Africa.
A KM of high quality copper wire is not cheap, either. To a central powerplant, distribution of fossil fuel to decentralized power plants is very expensive and very wasteful.
The economically developing world has a great problem in accessing capital, not in investing it usefully.
There is also the mess it creates with the grid. The business model of electrical companies is that in your monthly bill you pay for both power and for the grid that delivers it to you. If everyone puts solar on their roof it destroys the business model of the electrical companies and in the occasions where you still want to use grid power (at night, cloudy days etc) your rates will inevitably be higher or someone else has to pay for maintaining the grid and your socializing grid usage.
I think most of the hype around solar is way overdone. Too much solar can really can do lasting damage to an electrical grid and cause massive economic harm. This has happened in Germany where they subsidized renewables so much that they pushed out reliable power from the grid and now they are having the subsidize gas/coal generation so the grid will remain reliable. Furthermore, electricity prices have gone up enormously causing large industrial companies to move abroad or scale back operations. Electricity is the lifeblood of an economy and arbitrarily raising prices and messing with how electricity is delivered and managed can have large unintended consequences especially when decided by politicians who know nothing about the science or business.
You're right electricity is heavily regulated and has been for quite some time. Despite the regulation however most companies generally operate as a lowest cost to consumers basis. Consumers ask for the lowest prices and electricity companies tend to oblige.
When politicians decide they very often have some vested interest as a priority and try to raise rates by handing special favors to certain industries.
What makes you think when politicians make decisions based on whats best for consumers vs. whats best for whoever donated to their campaign? If you think renewable energy companies don't hire lobbyists you suffer from a disconnect from reality.
Also, you didn't argue my main point which is solar isn't competitive to other sources. Should everyone pay more for electricity?
The obvious, standard, free market answer to this (which it seems you'd be in favor of given the political elements of your argument) is some kind of carbon tax. With externalities accounted for wind and solar are the obvious market choices for new generation capacity (and efficiency is rewarded with correct prices too). They're often the best choice now even without this market correction, and continually drop in price to make this more common. That's why we're at some kind of tipping point and the old vested interests realise they're in danger.
(Note in actual implementations of this they often either return the money raised directly to consumers, or cut other taxes to compensate, so you pay more for some things, but still come out aheadahead overall).
You can see Elon Musk sigh every time he mentions this as it's so obviously the right answer, but politically toxic in the US, for no logical reason, despite it being the market friendly, small government answer. A tax specifically designed to phase itself out over time. Instead we've got a strange web of government subsidies and regulations because the democrats like those kind of thing, and the libertarian side of things has been bought off by the vested interests.
In fact the opposite is true. The only reason solar is being adopted at all in almost every region in the world is because of government subsidies.
(Source: I build solar and wind farms for a living).
And fossil fuels have a really great energy density. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density