News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @07:52PM (#10007161)
> Individual students certainly can have this integrity, but the demographic as a whole is demonstrably susceptible to cheating.

Certainly demonstrably true of a significant portion of the demographic of "college students".

Caltech would probably argue that Caltech students are not a representative sample of college students, and that generalization from the more general class to the more specific here is a textbook example of the fallacy of division.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by vacri on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @07:59PM (#10007204)
That's a 'begging the question' fallacy, where the conclusion ('Caltech students are more honourable than that') is used as the premise (ditto).

Even if we all agree that Caltech students are not representative of college students in general, it doesn't automatically follow that there is no significant degree of cheating.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:06PM (#10007233)
> That's a 'begging the question' fallacy, where the conclusion ('Caltech students are more honourable than that') is used as the premise (ditto).

No, its not. Rejecting the validity of an argument for p is not the same as making an argument for not-p.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by vacri on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:22PM (#10007307)
But that's exactly how you presented their supposed argument: "Caltech students don't cheat because they're not representative of the general student population", with the vague assumption that Caltech students are more honour-bound.

Not being representative of a population doesn't give any information about the makeup of the subsample, unless you have more information to add.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @10:18PM (#10007702)
> But that's exactly how you presented their supposed argument: "Caltech students don't cheat because they're not representative of the general student population"

No, its not, which is why you had to present a "quote" that isn't to advance that story.

I presented how they would reject an argument from the general population, not positive argument for the absence of cheating at Caltech.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by vacri on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @12:26AM (#10008015)
What are you talking about? You presented the argument as a potential rebuttal to the claim that students cheat. It's inherently implied that it's an argument for the absence of cheating at Caltech... otherwise it wouldn't be a rebuttal at all, and instead is a non-sequitur fallacy.

Yes, if you strip away the context of the literal words you said, you're correct. But in context, you're not.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by WalterBright on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:00PM (#10007208)
An interesting question is does Caltech's admissions process select (unwittingly or otherwise) people who are likely to follow the honor system, or do people tend to rise to an expectation of integrity? I suspect the latter is more likely.

I also suspect that a university with strong anti-cheating measures is expecting students to cheat, and students will naturally fulfill that expectation.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:08PM (#10007240)
> An interesting question is does Caltech's admissions process select (unwittingly or otherwise) people who are likely to follow the honor system, or do people tend to rise to an expectation of integrity?

I think the latter is definitely true, the former is probably true, and perhaps more importantly, Caltech's admissions process selects for people who are likely to view a system where rules are enforced primarily by monitoring as a challenge, making the alternative to trust being an arms race that consumes resources on both sides that could be more productively employed.

Re:Linus Torvalds did not commit this by vacri on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @08:18PM (#10007293)
Even if it selects for that trait, it doesn't mean that there isn't a significant level of cheating. You can reduce the incidence of X and still have problematic levels of X.

Edit: An example: the US homicide rate has fallen in recent years. That's good news. But the US still has a serious problem with homicide, as its homicide rate is an outlier at 4-5 times that of all other first-world nations. Americans are getting less murderous, but murder is still a serious problem there.