Re:Alan Kay – Normal Considered Harmful (2009) [video]
by bitwize on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @12:18PM
(#10004358)
I'm a bit surprised that Dr. Kay didn't fact-check the boiling frog story; modern biologists don't believe it has any basis in reality.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Alan Kay – Normal Considered Harmful (2009) [video]
by 26cf805ae26f on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @01:03PM
(#10004680)
You don't need to be a "modern biologist" to assert those claims. I just tried once and it worked (I mean the frog did die)
Re:Alan Kay – Normal Considered Harmful (2009) [video]
by mflindell on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @07:44PM
(#10007108)
I was worried about that too but I'm sure someone with a degree in biology would have figured that out, right? Pretty sure its meant as a metaphor
Re:Alan Kay – Normal Considered Harmful (2009) [video]
by dwmtm on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @01:33PM
(#10004867)
Do you really need to fact-check a metaphor?
Re:Alan Kay – Normal Considered Harmful (2009) [video]
by bitwize on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @02:20PM
(#10005216)
I mean it's a cute story and an idiom that is pretty much indelible from the language, but Kay was putting it in terms like it's a fact about frogs' biology when it is not. He has a background in biology as well as CS, so I am indeed surprised he didn't check this.
Re:Alan Kay – Normal Considered Harmful (2009) [video]
by e12e on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @02:43PM
(#10005363)
Appears to be inconclusive: "None of these modern rebuttals – Melton, Zug, or Hutchison's – attempts to replicate an extremely slow-heating experiment as cited by Goltz or Scripture: only Hutchison did a thermal trial at over five times Goltz's slow rate and over nine times Scripture's 0.002 °C per second temperature rise." [1]
More interesting is perhaps the question of how you get the frog to sit still -- or maybe change the experiment so there's a grid over the top of the pan -- and try to see if the frog gets more and more "desperate" (flight from danger as opposed to "just a frog jumping around") as the water slowly heats?