News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bertrand's Paradox by lordnacho on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @07:14AM (#10002631)
IMO the most natural interpretation of "random" with no qualifiers is the one that gives you 1/3. Pick a point, pick another point, a third of the time the second point in within the far arc of the triangle.

I'm not sure the ninja method gives you what I'd call a representative sample of possible chords. Looks like he only cuts vertically, so he can never give you a skew-slice.

Similar with the dragon.

Re:Bertrand's Paradox by chadzawistowski on Tuesday August 04, 2015 @02:50PM (#10005425)
It doesn't matter if he only cuts vertically in the animation. The pizza could be on a spinning wheel, and as long as it's a perfect circle, that wouldn't matter to the ninja's cuts.

User antimagic thought it was most natural to draw lines by picking random (x,y) coordinates on a plane, then overlaying a circle. This "natural" choice corresponds to selection method #2, so they ended up getting the 1/2 answer.