News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to France: We Won't Forget It for You Wholesale by e12e on Monday August 03, 2015 @08:15PM (#10000850)
Well, not quite. I do agree that RTBF as written is sorely lacking -- but I think the fundamental issue is interesting: Do we have a right to privacy? Do we have a right to our own data, and data about ourselves? Both are as I understand it part of the law both in the EU and in the USA.

The general mold (which AFAIK is quite similar across the EEC area, somewhat independent of the formation of the EEC/EU) -- is that a user has a right to a) make any (personal/sensitive) information stored is correct, and b) as an extension of various common legal principles one have the right to a new life after being acquitted, and after serving out a sentence.

Just those two things imply a need for a global accord on how data should be handled, indexed etc. The current RTBF framework is probably not the best approach -- but I think it misses the mark to simply equate it with censorship. Controlling information is of course technically censorship -- but there's a difference between having a legal recourse against defamation -- and erasing Tiananmen Square from history.

I do think we are right to be worried about the actual results of any legislation though.

If it wasn't so unlikely to actually get anywhere, one might want the UN, or the Haag to set up some form of accord -- as right to privacy, and right to manage information in digital archives (which are much more versatile, accessible, trivial to copy and linkable than traditional paper archives) have some definite overlap with human rights.

This isn't some insurmountable task; there appears to be wide co-operation on other kinds of data, such as child porn already -- even if the age of consent is very different in the (all of?) the US and much of Euorope.

There are no comments on this comment yet.