Re:Garbage Collection, Without the Noise or the Smell
by orthecreedence on Monday August 03, 2015 @06:55PM
(#10000457)
From what I've observed, distribution makes sense if your nodes are homogeneous. Centralization makes sense if your nodes are heterogeneous.
People are typically heterogeneous (various levels of training, apathy, emotions, stress) and getting them to recycle properly is impossible. If everyone were a robot with the exact same version of the exact same recycling firmware with no known bugs, distributed recycling would make absolute sense.
Re:Garbage Collection, Without the Noise or the Smell
by icebraining on Monday August 03, 2015 @07:29PM
(#10000605)
I'm gonna keep this example in mind next time I end up in a subthread about how centralization sucks and distribution is so awesome and unicorns.
It's not really a good example - the system is centralized either way, moving the separation task to one side or the other doesn't really change that.
I of course agree with your sentiment here. It scares me how general population has everything exactly backwards when it comes to aggregate effects. Fighting centralized sorting is one example. Fretting over unplugged chargers is another (savings here are minuscule; most people would save orders of magnitude more of energy if they stopped driving their cars so much and used public transport every now and then). It's as if people cared only about gestures and feeling good about themselves, and not about actual effects.