News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

yes_its_giles

Re:Ask PG: What have I done wrong? on Friday January 15, 2010 @05:55PM (#1056114)
you're making the same assumption I disagreed with two comments ago. to me, getting banned is not the negative part of the experience. the negative part of the experience is the bad habit of coming back to engage in more fruitless conversation when I could be off doing stuff. the more offensive my tone is on this site, the sooner I'll get banned again, the quicker I'll get on with something actually useful to do, and the better it'll be for me.

I should just follow my own advice and devolve into Tourette's syndrome. fuck you, you chinchilla rapist. (nothing personal.)

anyway, ALSO, none of this has anything to do with what I'm talking about, which is that HN's karma system incubates various dysfunctions, and that anyone who sets up any kind of points system on a social site is going to be setting up the rules of a game that people will then play and be emotionally invested in winning.

curious game, the only way to win is not to play. I'm going to throw away my password to this account, log out, and see how long I can last before starting account #4.

Re:Ask PG: What have I done wrong? on Friday January 15, 2010 @04:18PM (#1055908)
Yeah, exactly. It's a dysfunctional pattern. I enjoy it, but I really think there's a systemic tendency to dysfunctional patterns here. That's inevitable with any social software, so you have to plan for your dysfunctions. Look at Stack Overflow, the dysfunction they get is karma whores answering as many questions as possible, and competing to be first with the answer. That's a pretty great dysfunction. The dysfunction we have here is anybody who polarizes opinions gets banned. The cynical (me) find it amusing and the sensitive (Giraffes) get their feelings hurt. Either way, it's bad. You don't want a community which punishes anyone for voicing controversial opinions, but that's inherent to the design here.
Re:Ask PG: What have I done wrong? on Friday January 15, 2010 @12:49PM (#1055370)
I said I liked being banned. Why would I want to change something I like? It's a reminder to avoid getting into arguments with people who pay no attention to logic and have weird, arbitrary loyalties to systems which present no actual usefulness.
Re:Ask PG: What have I done wrong? on Friday January 15, 2010 @10:38AM (#1055065)
PPS, nothing against you, giraffes guy, I just re-read my sentence and it seemed a bit harsh.

I'm just saying that a web site that makes a person unhappy is not a good thing for them to be part of, and as someone who comes back repeatedly, despite being banned, to me it looks as if your desire to come back, despite being disenfranchised, is a sure sign of dysfunction. my coming back is certainly dysfunctional, but here I am. people dig the site in spite of its dysfunctions, but it sure would be cool if PG et al just threw the dysfunctional parts away.

Re:Ask PG: What have I done wrong? on Friday January 15, 2010 @10:32AM (#1055055)
Just create a new account. I get banned all the time. This is my third account. You can't take it personally. It's either some person being wrong about you or some automated system. Who cares?

I love it when I get banned, it means I won't be back for a while, until the desire for attention overcomes the inertia. This site is kinda like Get Satisfaction for bloggers. "You don't have to create an account. It's just that everybody on this one thread is talking about you right now, and they're all taking your lack of response to mean something."

I hate the karma system. Any site that has one is fundamentally flawed (detailed rant: http://gilesbowkett.blogspot.com/2008/05/summon-monsters-ope...). It's an automated, massively parallel abusive relationship, and I hate to kick somebody when they're down, but this guy, with all his sad whining about "I don't know what I did wrong, why don't you love me any more"? That is not the sign of a healthy community. That is the sign of an automated, massively parallel abusive relationship.

Any venture capitalist knows that you run a lot of experiments and some things fail. The karma system is fail. Throw it away.

PS, please ban me.

Re:Please teach kids programming, Mr. President (2009) on Thursday January 14, 2010 @02:07AM (#1052136)
hey, for what it's worth, I commented on this blog post, when it originally went up, saying that it's better to be the change you wish to see, HINT HINT, which means (in other words) I think it would be cool to actually DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS as opposed to chin-stroking about it all day long. (Or indeed, as it turned out, chin-stroking about it for years to come.)

If anybody feels the same way, e-mail me ([email protected]), because I'm totally not kidding. Actions speak louder than words. Less yammering, less yanking our weiners about how futuristic and enlightened we are, and absolutely NO MORE of the boring nitpicky dickwads saying why it won't work for some blah blah blah bullshit "I'll say anything to avoid getting off my ass and helping people" reason.

Fuck all that. Let's teach some kids tech literacy who wouldn't otherwise learn it and change the world already, even if it's just some tiny little piece of the world. Still better than nothing.

seriously, what's with you guys? I lost 75 pounds in 6 months. I couldn't have made my blog post about that more Hacker News bait than it already was. I know a lot of you saw it. and still the ratio of people talking about it to people doing it is like 10,000 to 1. and you'd still rather debate some tangentially relevant research.

google "Dr Joel Fuhrman." I lost 100 points of cholesterol in three months. 75 pounds in six months. all you do is you eat vegetables. there's a little more to it, but not much. it's easy. the guy has reams of case studies and science backing him up. my 100-point cholestrol dip barely even blipped on his radar personally - didn't even raise his eyebrows - because he sees it all the time, but just for comparison, my dad and my uncle both got 100-point drops in their cholesterol too, over the course of ten years, and their cardiologists were happy, because normal nutrition is so bad that ten years is an acceptable time frame for that. so: ten years' progress in two months' time.

seriously, this is a solved problem. this is like, "let's figure out how to get a computer into every home and office in America." they're already there! why are you trying to answer a solved problem?

you could spend your whole life debunking invalid theories, or you could just find the theory that works and run with it. which sounds like a more effective use of time?

Re:How I got 50,000 page views by simply being me on Friday January 08, 2010 @04:40PM (#1040499)
I just wanted to say, because I did a bunch of blogging recently about how you can drive traffic deliberately by picking fights, and did it while driving traffic deliberately by picking some fights: in the past I was getting these occasionally 10K+ pageview days just by being me (which is small compared to the 50K+ these guys are talking about), and then sort of either graduated or devolved (depending on your frame of reference) to getting similar numbers deliberately. Basically I figured out what was happening, out of curiousity, and once I had figured it out, that meant I then had the ability to do it deliberately. So now, sometimes, I do.

I think the "tribal aversion of engineers to marketing" thing is very valid - being able to drive traffic is useful, and engineers seem to think that building systems that reward driving traffic (such as Google) makes you a better person than using such a system successfully (if you want to make money with Google, you're going to need to drive some traffic). It's such an arbitrary thing. If the system is worth building then it must be worth using too.

You people on Hacker News need to figure something out about me. I don't address the obvious objections, because they're obvious. I just solve them and move on. This objection is so easy to solve it's not worth talking about.
Yes! I shall call it "Viaweb."

(Just kidding.)

Yeah, it's the Four-Hour Work Week thing. All you need is a business model which requires neither time nor energy and you're fucking DONE. So many lazy thinkers on a site like this. I never said I was starting businesses that require time or energy. I said I was starting businesses. Period, the end.

Apart from anything else, say for the sake of argument that it just offends your sense of logic to put together a business which requires time and energy, when you know business models exist which don't require much time or energy. Just assume, for the sake of argument, that it horrifies you to your core, this insane idea of wasting your precious moments on this earth making money the hard way when you could have made it with much less effort.

If you say "I'm launching a new business every month this year," you've just painted yourself into a corner which requires that you put together businesses that don't require time or energy. That's a good corner to be in. With our hypothetical, how do you feel about that corner? You feel pretty good.

But if you say "I'm going to set up one business this year, just one, only one, and after I make that choice, I'm committing to it for years", you're painting yourself into a different corner, where whichever business you choose to start, you're fucking stuck with it. It's your whole life now, for years to come. So you're going to hem and haw a long god damn time before you choose which kind of business to start, and when you finally make the choice, you might choose a shitty business model because it revolves around a technology which would be fun to build.

That's a bad corner. It's bad for your integrity and it's bad for your quality of life. (And this whole site is basically devoted to exalting that particular bad decision.)

Also, RubyFlow could become a Reddit or a TechCrunch. The fact that it isn't one now doesn't mean anything. The fiercest tiger starts life as a kitten. If you start 12 companies in a year, you can always come back to them a year later and decide to put a little more effort into a few of them and build them into larger things. I aimed for 12 miniapps last year. I didn't hit that mark, but I ended the year having built a bunch of miniapps, and one of them (Hacker Newspaper) I'm definitely going to keep around, and can, if I wish, add new features to. That's so much better than just building one thing and betting the farm on that one thing.

I mean there's a reason venture capitalists never bet the farm on one company.

Re:Giles Bowkett: No New Languages In 2010; New Businesses Instead on Wednesday December 30, 2009 @11:38PM (#1023826)
Starting a new business is hard. It takes time and energy.

Question your assumptions. They're wrong.