News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

xander23

Re:Cartography Comparison: Google Maps and Apple Maps on Saturday January 28, 2017 @03:32PM (#13509013)
> I think my counterpoint was stronger.

No, what I was saying was that your counterpoint isn't a counterpoint. A counterpoint would be: Google shouldn't show new kinds of things on the map (such as houses, small businesses, etc.).

The OP is talking about new kinds of things, while you're talking about the density of things. And the OP actually makes the same argument you're making a few paragraphs later:

> we’re also seeing the argument for map personalization: Not everyone uses transit, so there might be places—such as landmarks—that are more important to some people. And when it’s life-and-death, hospitals are the most important places in the world. But how often does the average person visit a hospital? Personalized maps are better at surfacing the most appropriate places for each person; but for the default map, something still has to be chosen… and that’s what we saw above.

Personalization is great, but something still has to be chosen for the default. That's why the default matters.

Re:Cartography Comparison: Google Maps and Apple Maps on Sunday January 15, 2017 @06:44PM (#13407194)
I just wanted to say thank you to author for this incredibly high quality, well done piece.

Looking forward to reading the next parts!

Re:Cartography Comparison: Google Maps and Apple Maps on Sunday January 15, 2017 @06:30PM (#13407115)
> Less is more. You don't want to show as much information as you can...

100% agree, but I don't think it's saying more is better.

Rather that because maps now have dozens of zoom-levels (as opposed to just 1 with paper maps), they can show all sorts of things that wouldn't have been included before. Things like houses, small businesses, etc. Things that would've never been on a paper map.

This makes the POI dead because now anything can be included, anything can be on the map (regardless of its importance).

(Example from my own experience: Google maps has an outline of my house on it and even my backyard tool shed. But I've never seen a paper map that also had this.)

Also 100% agree with you that personalization is awesome, but it seems like the whole point was specifically to examine the defaults. To see what decisions were made for the defaults and how it made the two different.