wrf3
Re:How to Disagree
on Saturday March 29, 2008 @04:41PM (#149643)
Attacking someone's credibility has no bearing on that person's argument. A true statement spoken by the devil doesn't make that statement false.
Next, it's very hard for someone to correctly divine the motives of another. It is often the case that it's easier to make up base motives and assign then to an opponent than it is to refute their argument.
Finally, that people "decide their position on an issue and then seek supporting evidence" simply shows that "people" are idiots.
Re:How to Disagree
on Saturday March 29, 2008 @03:02PM (#149576)
You might want to consider adding:
DH2.5. Denial
The form of this response is the basic "no, it isn't", without any other supporting details. As such, it falls below "DH3. Contradiction", which at least tries to advance the argument, even if not very well. Monty Python's "Argument Clinic" provides a well-known and amusing example of this.