News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

wbuckley

Re:RAMCloud on Friday November 27, 2015 @02:33PM (#10638539)
At a glance, this looks a lot like the underlying software running Texas Memory Systems' (now IBM) RamSan products, except built to run on off-the-shelf hardware of the user's choice, which is quite a nice development.

As a use-case example, those units have been in use for at least ten years by CCP Games [http://community.eveonline.com/news/news-channels/press-rele... and http://community.eveonline.com/news/dev-blogs/apocrypharrrrr...] as extreme-low-latency database storage for a fairly large cluster. At the time there were jokes of the staff needing to get special clearances just to see demo hardware before making their decision and eventual purchase due to restrictions related to their use by government and military customers.

Maybe I'm oversimplifying it or looking at it wrong, but I wanted to share my 2c while I was thinking about it. I'll take a better look later.

I'd say you've hit the nail squarely on the head here.

As an (amusingly directly relevant to the side-discussion) example, in a college English course I took we had a group project and presentation in which we had to take a position on an issue. Despite it being dangerous territory, my group dove directly into the vaccine debate. After beginning our research (note that this was prior to the major cited paper(s) on the issue being retracted) we decided that we would work very carefully, within the guidelines of the project, to advocate that any and all possible links should be researched farther. Technically this position was not a great fit for the directions we had been given, but we wanted to be very careful to say "this might be an issue and should be investigated in more detail" rather than "this is a problem and we fix it with [x]."

TL;DR: Taking the hard line is often a bad call, but calling for something to be looked into (with cause) is often wise. If you read the newsgroup post to the end, this is exactly what the author does, albeit with some important context to the issue omitted.