wattle_park
The reason they received huge numbers of applicants because their criteria was wide and IMHO misleading.
The originals partners were brilliant founders. They were not young (drop out or out of college) founders. They had 'life' experiences. So they were very nurturing and compassionate and patient. They helped young smart founders to build companies and many become successful companies. With the current goals of scaling fast, and many new partners YC has diluted its success recipe. It's not about 'making what people want' anymore. It's about making what 20 something year old who live in the valley want.
Jessica Livingstone's book 'Founders at Work' contains many different types of founders. And not many of them were fresh out of college or college drop outs.
YC has become a big company, and along the way YC has contributed to build Silicon Valley as the center for technology. However, it needs to have big companies responsibilities as well.
The sample population was chosen by specific type of groups of partners. There is no female technical partners in the group. As a female technical founder, I am not interested in building 'tea-making bot', sandwich making bot or selling organic condom. IMHO we have different views in looking at problems and solving them. Without having female technical founder as partner, YC would be perceived to be biased.
The algorithm of selecting promising candidates will vary once there is a variety of partners.