vlerenc
I mean, either I have to deploy Bosh or Kubernetes (to deploy more Kubernetes clusters, because that's what we are speaking of here). Kubernetes is now commodity. The idea is to place Kubernetes control planes into Kubernetes clusters (like it became good practice to deploy the OpenStack control planes) and benefit from all the advantages Kubernetes brings along. No need to go for another tool, but there are more points: - First off, Bosh is no thing in the Kubernetes community – it is primarily a tool used in the context of Cloud Foundry. - By using Kubernetes to manage itself you have less components, less learning. It is there already and everybody who works with Kubernetes doesn’t need to pick up yet another technology. - Bosh provisions VMs, which are slow to provision. What takes minutes with Bosh, takes seconds with Kubernetes. - VMs lead to massive fragmentation as they are mostly under-utilized and in the worst case over-utilized. - Bosh can’t scale processes as it commandeers only VMs, while in Kubernetes everything is a pod/container that can scale up or out automatically using the VPA/HPA. - Using the Bosh Kubernetes CPI has other disadvantages we can discuss in breadth, but I don't think we should, because its experimental at best and I know no installation actually running on it. - Bosh can’s scale VMs automatically, while Kubernetes can. If the cluster is nearing saturation, the cluster-autoscaler provisions more VMs on-the-fly (or shrinks the cluster back). - Bosh uses outdated Monit to watch over single processes, while Kubernetes pods are managed by the container engine on the lower level and by Kubernetes itself on the higher level. - Bosh depends on rather large Ubuntu-based or CentOS Pivotal stemcells (with the Bosh agent) and Pivotal updating them, while there are much light-weighter options like CoreOS Container Linux and no lock-in (you can take almost any OS). - Bosh packages all software into proprietary Bosh Releases and doesn’t isolate the VM processes, while with Kubernetes you create individual images and run them as isolated containers.
The list goes on and on and it is unlikely that Bosh can catch up again (the Pivotal IPO statement seems to indicate the same as major risk [1]). Kubernetes is the new virtualization layer and is made to run software reliably with minimal TCO. I have seen this in practice - Kubernetes is absolutely amazing - also/especially for these types of workloads.
[1] https://techcrunch.com/2018/03/23/pivotal-software-files-for...