vc_investor
I agree that companies pursuing small opportunities (web 2.0 features, iPhone/Facebook apps, etc.) will face little competition from funded competitors. That's because there's little money to be made out of those innovations. In the short term, that may even apply to situations where the prize is large (Skype, Google, Facebook, etc.).
But in the longer term, economic systems operate in equilibrium, so you have to think about marginal not absolute factors. In equilibrium, competition will increase, and in turn cost of supply (of developers, airtime, etc.) will scale, in proportion to the size of the prize. Only proprietary cost advantages offer sustainable competitive advantage, whereas free software tools, cloud hosting, and cheap airtime benefit all contestants equally. When credible signalling costs are high and transparency is low, relative early advantage tends to be self-reinforcing. So when the pie is big enough, unfunded start-ups will find their marginal rate of growth just as constrained by a lack of capital as it's ever been, and will lose the initiative to better-funded rivals accordingly. Which means VCs will be just as essential in supporting high-value product development as ever.
Of course, you might say that the rate at which the marginal utility of wealth declines is high enough that few rational entrepreneurs will be motivated to pursue big new product innovations given the higher likelihood of failure compared to developing iPhone apps. In practice I tend to think that success for most entrepeneurially-minded individuals is as much about recognition (a positional good), as it is about absolute wealth. And again, in equilibrium, position goods are definitively scarce, meaning the arms race for status will continue ad infinitum.
There's an old adage about how to make money: sell bullets in the war without end. That's what VCs do. And the invention of the taser doesn't put gun makers out of business. On the contrary, it increases their utility.
More generally, no, I do not see any trend in rounds getting significantly smaller. I do see a trend in pre-money valuations coming down, of course, but that's entirely different.
The economics of bulge-bracket VC work when you invest say ~5% of your fund in each portfolio company, in the hope that 1/10 or 1/20 of your companies will hit it out of the park. Total fund size equilibriates when drivers for scale (partners' remuneration, principally, less relatively invariable overheads) balances with diseconomies from political inference effects which kick in when too many partners try to reach consensus and cut the cake. That's why top tier firms with a 'plain vanilla' strategy have roughly comparable fund sizes.
FUD aside, nothing I'm seeing at the moment that gives me any reason to believe that underlying model is 'broken' or failing (though of course '07 and '08 vintages will be shot). Almost all successful start-ups need a lot of money to scale beyond a certain point. Free software doesn't really change the cost of airtime, or a VP bus dev. I'm writing anonymously so I have no real axe to grind in saying that.
What is certainly happening in the industry is a shake-out. Good firms with strong reputations are raising quickly and comfortably (if quietly because it's not a time to be above the parapet), and will continue to invest without interruption. That is because there are well-priced deals to do in this environment, and innovation doesn't stop in a recession.
A number of 2nd tier firms, on the other hand, are finding fundraising very difficult. Many will not survive.
Firms that are thriving seem to be investing more slowly just at the moment. This is because there is a lot of noise in the market, and visibility is currently low. Analogy: when it's foggy you drive slower. (Economically: transaction costs rise as expectations less aligned, so liquidity declines.)
What is tough is the squeeze at the bottom end for start-ups. I get the impression (though have less direct evidence of this) that there is a bit less easy money on offer from HNWs sub $500k as many are licking wounds, etc.
In this market, where 'flat is the new up', I'd regard having founders cash out at early institutional rounds as unusual. There is comparatively little money being invested at the moment, and its a "buyers' market" which is to say that entrepeneurs have less negotiating power at present than they did when things were frothy.