News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

underreact

Re:Why College Students Leave the Engineering Track on Friday January 20, 2012 @09:06PM (#3492282)
It's interesting. I guess to me programming a computer seems more clear, because presumably whoever created the programming language did so with the intention that it should actually be useful for programming ( C++ jokes aside. ) But people can be complicated, inconsistent, and resistant to the idea that they can be won over with a simple formula. I suppose it just depends on the teacher.
Re:Why College Students Leave the Engineering Track on Friday January 20, 2012 @07:28PM (#3492012)
I'm working on a bachelors degree in cognitive science so I end up taking some classes related to math and programming, and some softer classes related to psychology. And I like to choose liberal arts subjects when I can for general ed, for the sake of being well-rounded.

I find non-hard-science courses to be a little easier in general, but not much easier and not always. You sometimes get professors in a subject like art history who have very specific ideas about how an essay should be structured and what elements are legitimate topics of discussion. Being grammatically correct is often not good enough. There can be quite a bit of intellectual challenge in figuring out what type of essay will result in a good grade, and being able to do this sort of thing may translate into increased chances of success in terms of dealing with customers, coworkers, or managers.

At this point I consider it easier to write a program than an essay. At least with a program there is a standard for the language, and a compiler for me to test the outcomes with before I turn it in. The absolute nature of discrete math can be a comfort, not a difficulty.

I think some CS Engineers get a biased view of other subjects because they only take the introductory or elementary versions of other courses. Some English major may have to stretch his brain for many hours to decipher the meaning of something written hundreds of years ago, in a different dialect and with the context of a different time period; it would be wrong for him to dismiss electrical engineering just because he thought that applying the power rule in calculus 1 wasn't that hard.

And philosophy majors get this type of "soft-major" criticism the most, but let us not forget that our computers are philosophy machines.

Edit: I add this to note that cparedes made similar points as I typed this