News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

twqtisgreatbut

Re:Qt 5.6.0 released on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @06:49PM (#11301290)
Its not helpful, they aren't complying with the relinking clause. I don't think there's any way to use LGPL with closed source on mobile app stores.
Re:Qt 5.6.0 released on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @06:25PM (#11301157)
The problem isn't dynamic linking, its the requirement that the end user must be able to re-link a modified version of the LGPL code. So for example, the user should be able to replace the Qt libraries your application links to. On closed platforms like iOS and Android (on Google Play) this isn't really possible. How would your user access your application, modify it and re-sign it?
Re:Qt 5.6.0 released on Wednesday March 16, 2016 @04:10PM (#11300300)
I really like Qt and think its an incredible framework overall. Even if you don't use the Qt libraries, QtCreator is one of the best C++ IDEs out there imo (though qmake really sucks and they've been dragging their feet on a proper replacement for years)

The real show stopper for me with Qt is its licensing though. LGPL is a no-go on closed mobile platforms and its commercial license at $350/month is completely unreasonable for smaller developers. Really, the LGPL is a horrible license because of its clause that you must be able to change out the LGPL portion of the software.

Also almost every time there's a thread about Qt I see a bunch of (presumably) web developers start talking about React. In fact, in pretty much every thread talking about any similar framework someone has to mention React. I'm not a web developer and I've only looked at React briefly but I guess I just don't get it. Could someone explain succinctly what the big deal is? I've used Qt a lot -- what do all these people mentioning React want Qt to offer? Why is it brought up so often? Is it really that revolutionary? Almost seems like a cult.