throwaway284243
throwaway284243 on Hacker News
Yeah, so maybe it would be better if "hackers" simply start working alongside the rest of society, and give up trying to force misplaced and awkward hippie ideals into their planning meeting, that makes their work completely incompatible with the rest of the organisation, and society?
Yep, at the end of the day, the whole world can't run if everyone is a professor emeritus just freely exploring random possibilities, even if it would be hundred times more efficient to just "get out of the way".
Because your organisation answers to shareholders on a quarterly basis.
Next performance review, your manager goes: It seems like you're not really aware of a lot of techniques of how to solve problems efficiently. Maybe you should do more pairing with the other seemingly much better developers to strengthen your skills. And now you've cornered yourself as a junior for the next 2 years, who was "hired on the wrong level".
All of this is assuming that the team members will prioritise the performance of the team higher than their own performance, of which there are no incentives. The incentives is to make yourself look as good as possible (don't admit your idea is inferior), and skew the playing field to your advantage (insist on using the tools you know best) etc.
People simply don't spontaneously cooperate and simply don't "just get along" in a situation like this.
Even in hippie communities where everything is voluntary and there is no personal gain to be had, it still falls apart because some people just don't cooperate.
So how do you expect that to happen in a situation with money involved, and competition between people?
Why do the software industry and scrum think they have spontaneously discovered how people always just get along, inside a basic weekly planning schedule? That would literally be a nobel peace prize right there.