throwaway1124
throwaway1124 on Hacker News
Even if they raised a convertible note or pure debt (which is atypical of a First Round Capital led round), it is unlikely that their 409A led to an extremely low FMV. Even a company that raises $2M in debt at a $6M cap would likely have a common share valuation over $500K.
Source: I'm a previous founder of a startup that raised a $1.5M convertible note and have done a 409A valuation based on it.
I'm not suggesting that the valuation is truly worth $1.2M but if they did a 409A valuation or had their board decide on the FMV to determine strike price, the value would be at least 15% of the post-money valuation. My point is simply that if they've issued a reasonable number of options (over 0.25% of the total authorized shares), there is no way that their employees would only pay a few hundred dollars to exercise.
In an extended exercise period model, there's still the issue of Alternative Minimum Tax on exercise or long-term vs. short term capital gains. There will also likely be lockups on those shares whether inherently built in or in an eventual IPO.
I agree. I think that in the earliest stages, startups should consider "bonus-ing" out the employees to exercise their options early. I'm wondering what the consequences/disadvantages would be for the startup.
I appreciate the thinking here and message but am concerned about this line "This will cost a few hundred dollars at most".
Clearbit has raised a $2M seed round from top-tier investors implying a post-money valuation likely over $6M. A conservative FMV of the common shares would suggest a $1.2M valuation. To exercise a 0.5% of total equity grant would cost $6,000. Something doesn't add up here.
If I am correct, will Clearbit help its employees exercise their options?
See: https://www.fenwick.com/publications/pages/playing-with-fire...
In seed stage companies, what is the disadvantage of enabling your employees to early exercise and bonus-ing or loaning them the capital to do so?
The advantage seem clear: employees can get 25-35% more equity at effectively no cost difference to the company.