thomax
"creator of app for collecting unsolicited feedback can't handle unsolicited feedback" etc.
Some nice spoonfuls if irony, right there.
Still, however you look at this rule, there are a lot of gray areas, and policing those must be challenging. I'd also guess that with an IPO on the horizon, the Etsy shareholders probably favor high volumes on their website, rather than kicking out shops that peddle non-handmade merch. A pity, that, because It's sorta the opposite of what Etsy was supposed to be.
Which leaves us with discussing what reasonable circumstance is.
You'd argue that fencing off a five mile long beautiful beach so that nobody else can enjoy this land is reasonable. I'd argue to the contrary, and it seems judge Barbara Mallach, at least, is with me on that one.
To go along with your car example, there are relationships which trump ownership. In the US, if a uniformed police officer approaches you and requests the use of your car in order to prevent a serious crime, you must comply. The cop's dire need to access your vehicle trumps the ownership of your car. Sure, you still own your car, but somebody else needs it a lot more right now.
Same thing in Norway regarding land ownership. Sure, you own it, but public access to that land may in some cases trump ownership.
Where I come from (Norway) a land owner needs a good reason to deny the public access to the land. Such a reason might be that the land is very small and surrounding a house (typically a garden), or there are crops planted or animals grazing on the land (typically a farm).
A land owner can't just put up a fence, but is free to develop the land (within county restrictions) or sell it and pocket the money.
Yeah, too bad for introvert billionaires, but hey, most people aren't and that's democracy for ya.