News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

thomasliao

Re:Why eval startups fail (2025) on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @06:08AM (#48657596)
>equally "frontier" models

A key point I want to make is that the notion of "frontier" is somewhat fictive in the sense that a model which dominates all others on a given eval is not guaranteed to be number one on another eval, even if both evals are ostensibly for the same task.

For example, the best publicly-available model (i.e. excluding Claude Mythos and Fable) on DeepSWE[0] is gpt-5.5-xhigh at 67%, which is soundly better than claude-opus-4.8-max at 59%. I would say an 8pp gap on a benchmark is quite large. But on FrontierCode[1], claude-opus-4.8-xhigh is the best, at a score of 13.4% compared to gpt-5.5-medium at 6.3%.

That's quite a significant reversal!

Now, one might wish to claim that either DeepSWE or FrontierCode is poorly constructed and that the other is more accurate. But I think you'll find that the degree to which eval-design considerations in this case affect measurement is probably of no less magnitude than user-specific considerations affect measurement in general.

[0] https://deepswe.datacurve.ai/ [1] https://cognition.com/blog/frontier-code

Re:Why eval startups fail (2025) on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @05:34AM (#48657354)
It's an important question! If you are paying a lot of money to use AI models, you care that you are using the best for your task. And it turns out that figuring out which AI models is best for your task is not trivial and requires some expertise.
Re:Why eval startups fail (2025) on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @05:31AM (#48657323)
(Author) It's short for "evaluation", a test for an AI model. Specifically, an AI evaluation comprises (1) a dataset of prompts (as questions / tasks / queries), (2) some way to score model performance on each prompt, like a set of correct answers or a grading rubric that you can use with an LLM autograder, and (3) a metric, such as accuracy¹. (If you're already familiar with the term "benchmark", it's the same thing; for some reason the former has become the term of art in the past few years).

For example, a simple eval is a dataset of multiple-choice questions, which each have one correct answer, and scored by accuracy. An example of this kind of eval is the Massive Multitask Language Understanding benchmark (2020) (https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.03300).

A more complex eval is FrontierCode (2026). Questions in FrontierCode represent coding tasks needed for real-world repos and are evaluated against rubrics scoring for correctness, code quality, cleanliness, and other factors. https://cognition.com/blog/frontier-code.

¹Note that this is a slightly different definition we used in [0], which used a definition of a fixed input-output correspondence pairs combined with a metric. What's different from 2021 is: models are now given more open-ended inputs (prompts like "find the bug" and a codebase rather than a simple question), have freeform generation (rather than choosing a fixed answer), and are graded in a more complex manner (e.g. beyond correctness, one might care for a coding eval also to grade adherence to coding guidelines, test coverage, etc).

[0] Liao, T., Taori, R., Raji, I. D., & Schmidt, L. (2021, January). Are we learning yet? a meta review of evaluation failures across machine learning. In Thirty-fifth Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems Datasets and Benchmarks Track (Round 2). https://thomasliao.com/are_we_learning_yet.pdf