thescrutinizer
The impression I got of this space:
1. Clients, usually executives within large, billion dollar companies, don't really mind spending what for them are pennies on a subscription from a company that claims to know what's up when they feel they don't. They see a company with certain associated credentials and trust the advice.
2. Executives, wishing to justify their own decisions, want to cover their own asses by appealing to "experts". Their employers may come across those reports, see their company ranking highly, and say "Wow, Bob. You've done a great job." It matters little how meaningful the data analysis is. The data analysis is just decorative.
3. The ranking in reports become a self-fulfilling prophecy of sorts. If you rank highly in an advisory report on a certain kind of product, and readers of that report believe the ranking, then this can lead to more sales or whatever.
To be fair, this isn't some kind of Newtonian mechanics. You can't take a bunch of data and just have all your conclusions fall out as a tidy positions in space and time. I am not making the claim that advice cannot be given or that these things cannot be researched to produce meaningful insight. I also do not claim that there are no companies out there producing valuable research. However, my personal experience does make me wonder. Even if and when the claims in the research are true, the appeals to data can become little more than a game of appearances. Maybe, in relative terms, they're not in much worse shape than academia with its data massaging, p-value hacking scandals, and unreplicated/unreplicable studies.