theomarkettos
We're working on porting to a cheaper FPGA-on-PCIe board, but it's still ~EUR 800.
Second, the prompt says 'you attached a thing, do you want to allow it?'. The name is often not descriptive, eg 'CalDigit TS3' in our example, so users can't tell what rights are being asked for. As we've found on mobile, when apps pop up prompts about permissions users are conditioned to agree. Also, users can be deceived by putting a sticker on the malicious device with the name on the prompt - the writing on the plastic agrees with the prompt, so the device must be legit. An attacker can also play social engineering tricks - "say 'approve' to enable fast charging" for example.
Finally, it's possible to swap out the PCIe devices behind a Thunderbolt bridge without re-prompting. We took a commercial Thunderbolt dock, removed the PCB with the dock's PCIe peripherals and replaced it with another PCIe card. Windows did not notice that the device had changed and didn't prompt again.
Fair point about hand soldering, however it would be more obvious to the manufacturing employees for an entire production batch to be diverted to have parts added manually than to simply sneak in another reel to the hundred on the pick and place machine.