News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

thejoshwolfe

Re:NetHack: The Greatest Game You Will Ever Play on Sunday March 20, 2016 @01:52PM (#11323838)
I love Nethack, but ultimately, I think it's a bad game. I decided to make my own game inspired by Nethack that fixes Nethack's mistakes: http://wolfesoftware.com/legend-of-swarkland/

I was greatly disappointed by Nethack's codebase, mostly by how inelegant and special-casey it is. (For example, the fact that mind flayers turn to stone when attacking a cockatrice is programmed in three separate places depending on who's the mind flayer and who's the cockatrice: uhitm.c, mhitu.c, and mhitm.c).

There are also fundamental flaws with the game's design, like as clever as it is to implement Sokoban with boulders and pits, it doesn't belong in a dungeon crawler, because random monster spawns can cheat you of a fair solution. The mazes of Gehenom are too long and boring. The plane of water makes no sense. The list goes on.

Another problem with nethack is how it punishes you for playing the game without spoilers. If you don't read a wiki (or the source), you're going to lose all your hours of progress to a bit of trivia you didn't know, like Medusa instakills you unless you're wearing X, Y, or Z. Trial and error can be good game design, but the retry period has to be short. In Nethack, it takes hours to recover from a line of code you couldn't possibly predict. (Wouldn't it be nice if fortune cookies or the Oracle were a reliable source of information? Really, you need to just read the wiki.)

As great as nethack is for its complexity and immersion, there are too many flaws for me to recommend it as a good game. That's why I'm trying to make my own game that's as complex as nethack, but doesn't have all the flaws, large and small.