thefunkychook
I don't quite follow why you're making a distinction for non-lazy languages?
If you want to actually use any generic monad combinators with your monad interface, and expect it to behave sensibly, then the laws had better be satisfied!
But yeah... Nice article, and I really liked your "Noun / Adjective" distinction.
As I understand it, one thing the tutorial didn't go into, which I think is an important subtlety, is that it's not enough to have an implementation of "bind" to have a monad interface. You also need an implementation of "return : a -> m a" (i.e. a way of making sources of 'a's when given an 'a'), AND a proof that these implementations together satisfy the monad laws (i.e. that they "play nicely" together).
Without all three components, you can have something that "looks like" a monad, in that it has definitions for "bind" and "return", but isn't actually one, because those particular definitions don't also satisfy the monad laws.
The only way out of this, while retaining some shred of humanity is through diplomacy, upholding international law, and centring the role of civil society and the huge numbers on both sides who want a peaceful, just coexistence.
The whole thing is sickening. Also hard to see how this can possibly improve Israel's security in the long term.