the_real_swa
Re:Rocky Linux from CIQ – Hardened
on Sunday March 23, 2025 @04:06AM (#43451506)
Yet RH publicly threatened to close your account/subscriptions when you DO exercise the rights of FOSS binaries if you download and redistribute the sources. This is different than giving 3rd parties access to the mentioned SERVICE [that would be equivalent to sharing your user name and passwords]. CIQ on the other hand actively distributes the sources of Rocky via the OpenELA and other githubs [Warewulf etc.]. Needless to say, but the GPL is about your rights downstream and not 'look we have upstream policies first [in Stream] but if you do redistribute sources of GPL stuff, your account is gone!'. No comparison in my book. Finally, logically, if you still find otherwise, then if CIQ is wrong then also RH is wrong and then also put the onus on BOTH.
Re:Rocky Linux from CIQ – Hardened
on Saturday March 22, 2025 @06:10AM (#43444683)
Re:Rocky Linux from CIQ – Hardened
on Saturday March 22, 2025 @04:02AM (#43444293)
https://ciq.com/legal/eula/rocky-linux-from-ciq/
" .... The license granted in this Section 4 is conditioned upon Customer’s and its Authorized Users ’compliance with this Agreement. To the extent that the Software provided to you is not under an open source license, ...."
missed that part?
Now check the RHEL EULA wrt distributing the SOURCES of the FOSS based binaries.