News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

ta1647960311

Re:The takeover of America's legal system on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @10:58AM (#30766865)
> One criminal law professor at a top law school told me he’s even stopped teaching theories of punishment because of how negatively students react to retributivism—the view that punishment is justified because criminals deserve to suffer.

While stopping teaching due to student fragility is rather unfortunate. I have to say this is one aspect of America's brand of justice that I think needs to change. My lay understanding is that retribution simply does not work -- and often is actually counterproductive, especially once you price in the cost of enacting the retribution. Furthermore a vengeful society or plaintiff needs to have some cooling off time, or spiritual growth to come to grips with the reality that life is full of horrific things and that making the best of it (neither nihilism nor resentfulness) is the true optimization of the system.

Instead I'd suggest that American justice needs to focus purely on rehabilitation. How can what remains be optimized? Yes that might even include giving an education to a <insert deplorable> so that they can contribute net positively to society.

Re:The takeover of America's legal system on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @10:52AM (#30766785)
> These trends are hitting academia and the non-profit sector first. At my law school, one of the top ones in the country, the Dean got up and declared himself a “white supremacist” at a town hall meeting: https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/northwestern-univers...

The only thing shown here is the fear of being ostracized, and the costs with being contrarian. You think this was contrition? I think it was simply them realizing they were better off lying than being genuine.

Re:The takeover of America's legal system on Tuesday March 22, 2022 @10:48AM (#30766742)
> and to a lesser extent, the court system, are shaped by and largely serve the needs of businesses

Meanwhile many businesses are starting to adopt the ideologies complained about in the article. Soon you won't be a viable option for providing services if you do not bear the mark "anti-racist" . Already my employer would likely retaliate and/or limit my career if it was found that I commented anything but purely affirmative towards all forms of anti-racist or critical race theory rhetoric. A rhetoric that completely strips me of any credibility due to my race and gender.