News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

simplesimon

Re:Building a house for under $5000 on Sunday May 24, 2009 @06:23PM (#624728)
I've just been blown away reading this fantasic debate - thank you. I really hear netsp's point. I am the author and It makes me feel like apologising for being so judgemental.

I started out on this road as one of the "people who do have a preference to live this way without any eco-political agendas", at least not that I was consciously aware of. Then I think two main things happened.

1. I was subject to a positive feedback loop that goes roughly - the more time I spent in nature - the more I loved and understood it - the more concern I had for ecological issues - the more i wanted to live more harmoniously with nature - the more inclination to workwith and care for the land - the more time spent in nature and so on

after some years seems i've inadvertently drifted into a position where i'm questionably become a radical and i definitely do have a concious eco-political agenda

2. I have experienced the resistance to the sort of thing we're doing. It simply goes against the status quo which there are many vested interests in preserving. So I see that whilst the construction industry is causing investment and in turn economic growth it must be preserved and expanded. Where it's business can be made more complex,there are new markets and room for growth. Then I see the industry satisfying the needs of growth and profit before its customers needs for shelter which could actually be achieved more effectively in simpler ways.

So if I sound critical or angry its the part of me that feels like people are being conned into expensive, unhealthy houses without being allowed or even told about the alternatives.

I am critical of conventional modern houses. I am NOT critical of people who live in them. I would like to be sure that they have the choice and that they understand the implications of their choice.

I am critical of modern construction techniques and of modern agriculture because they are not sustainable ie. they cannot continue to work in this way - this is a practical problem for us all regardless of whether or not it is a moral one. Finding systems to provide food and shelter for the long term are important problems that will require good design and judgement. I hope that in trying to practice and share good judgement of these systems I don't come across as judgemental of the people who use them.