sheavalentine
Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age in SF compa...
on Monday February 29, 2016 @03:59PM (#11198448)
The coffeeshop already pays more through conventional rent than the hedgefund in this example. Google also would pay substantially. More importantly, the people who have speculated the nearby city because of Google would pay a lot more.
Let's not forget the coffeeshop also make more money from being where it is.
Re:Nothing Like This Has Ever Happened Before – Gilded age in SF compa...
on Monday February 29, 2016 @03:55PM (#11198401)
What makes the land valuable to the factory? Serious question. You have the factory there, presumably a big factory was the best available use of that land.
Then people move to live around the factory. Are you suggesting that houses suddenly become the best available use? Because that doesn't make a lot of sense.
Of course the value does go up, but thats because the factory now has ready access to a population of employees. Did the factory build the houses around it that enabled that? No! So the amount the factories taxes go up from LVT is exactly equal to its net benefit from having a population near it ready to act as a labor pool. In other words, it has lost nothing from the tax, but merely failed to gain economic advantage simply from controlling the land.