sfgnu89q3
In the interest of teaching students real science and encouraging critical thinking, what should we do? Even if the growth mindset works, the fact that it works doesn't imply we should teach it.
A "growth mindset" is a scientific belief. It's not a personality trait, a positive outlook, or some sort of optimism. It is the belief that intelligence can be improved through hard work.
(You may notice that I consistently have "growth mindset" in scare quotes. A "growth mindset" is a scientific belief, and I wouldn't call it a "mindset" any more than I'd say doctors have a "germ theory mindset" or physicists have a "Copenhagen mindset.")
How intelligence works is a scientific problem. Encouraging a "growth mindset" because it makes students do better means weighing in on one side of the debate just because we like its conclusions.
If intelligence is largely fixed, as I believe it is, then encouraging a growth mindset means lying to people because we think they can't handle the truth. That might be the right thing to do, but it's a dangerous habit to get into.
Test-retest reliability / concurrent reliability (not sure which applies):
Doesn't look great. Grades can vary dramatically between classes, even if those classes are closely related.
Predictive validity:
Not sure. I'm not sure what, if anything, GPA is meant to predict, and I've read varying things about how well it predicts success in one's career.
Face validity / construct validity:
Abysmal. What are grades supposed to measure, anyway? Work ethic? Motivation? Willingness to obey authority? Intelligence? Demonstrated mastery of the material? I have no idea.
Whatever they're meant to measure, they measure a lot of things no one would want them to, like the student's race and sex, whether or not they're working while in school, when the class starts, etc.
Let me start by saying that I don't believe a word of it. The evidence I have seen suggests that intelligence is important in pretty much all intellectual activities, can be accurately measured by IQ tests, and cannot be improved. This is also, as far as I can tell, the strong consensus of the psychological community.
Assuming this is true, the proliferation of this "growth mindset" thinking has at least two scary thoughts:
1. If we encourage people to adopt a growth mindset because it will make them do better, than we are telling them what to believe without caring whether or not it is true. We are encouraging the adoption of convenient beliefs. Is that what educators should do?
2. It may lead to building an even more unequal society than the one we already have. Imagine the person who has no natural ability at all in a given field and does not succeed in it. If that person has a fixed mindset, they can conclude they have no ability and move on. If that person has a growth mindset, will they have any other option than to blame themselves for being lazy? A growth mindset means that mere bad luck is turned into culpability. Success is largely the product of luck, whether due to the wealth of one's parents or one's natural ability. If everyone in society adopts a growth mindset, then successful people can claim they are morally superior than people who fail.
Even assuming this research is accurate, it's not some happy uplifting story about how being positive can solve all your problems. It's a nasty ethical can of worms.