News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

saugnsckuigfh

Which is why the issue remains, as it has been since Quill, the extent of the seller's contacts with the state.

If you're making $100k to each 50 states, then you've got $50 Million in Revenue and can afford to do it.

If you've sold 10 t-shirts at $20 a piece, then your total sales of $200 isn't worth bothering with.

If we want there to be problems we can certainly create them, but doesn't seem all that complicated if we want it to work.

I find it highly unlikely that mom-and-pop stores will have to collect and remit taxes to other states.

From they very start of Quill they said: "we ruled that a "seller whose only connection ... is by common carrier ... lacked the requisite minimum contacts with the State." So the issue was: how substantial does the seller's contact have to be?

The court ends this decision by saying "the first prong ... asks whether the tax applies to an activity with a substantial nexus with the taxing State... sellers who engage in a significant quantity ... are large, national companies ... undoubtedly maintain an extensive virtual presence." So the issue remains: how substantial does the seller's contact have to be?

The underlying logic of the law hasn't changed, they just fixed some imprudently broad language referring to a physical presence.

So I doubt the SCOTUS abandoned one bright-line rule for being flawed in favor of another bright-line rule that equally fails to address the underlying issue of substantiality (e.g. imposing a "single-sale" rule).