News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

rodri_vera

Re:Why Germany Educates International Students for Free on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:14AM (#14306648)
It is not the same to have level C1 (completely fluent) in German and having the vocabulary and level to study at a German university. Exams in Germany are never multiple-choice and require you to write with a scientific vocabulary and idioms. This means an additional year of intensive German alone to have the vocabulary to pass exams at university.
Re:Why Germany Educates International Students for Free on Sunday April 30, 2017 @08:28AM (#14231229)
It is not so easy. It takes a lot of time to get a good level of German: At least 1 year of intensive courses, eventually 2. After this, you have to take Studienkolleg, if you want to have a chance at graduating. German universities are really challenging. In addition, as a foreign student, you will take longer than your German peers to graduate. In total to get a bachelor, you need to invest somewhere between 6-7 years. It is a lot of time (and money) for most people.

The worst part is that you do not have a guarantee that you will graduate. I knew many cases of foreign students, who invested 3-4 years of their life and were expelled from the university for failing their final exams. They returned home with nothing on their hands.

Re:Why Germany Educates International Students for Free on Sunday April 30, 2017 @08:24AM (#14231216)
I agree, we were told the same thing, when I was a full-degree foreign student in Bavaria: They do this as part of their foreign policy and they expect us to go back home to help develop our country and ideally do business with German businesses.
Re:Why Germany Educates International Students for Free on Sunday April 30, 2017 @08:20AM (#14231206)
The article has many points that are not correct. I was a foreign student who did studienkolleg (preparatory university course), bachelor and master degrees in German in Bavaria. In total, I spent 6 years in their educational system.

One thing to highlight is that German universities are very different to the American system of small groups, interaction with students, labs, hand-holding, etc. Traditional German education is one where you are not obliged to go to classes and you only have one final exam at the end of the semester. Some classes had up to 800 students. In other classes, we never got to see the professor and we were taught by a PhD student. Nobody knew your name and you were just another face, if you ever showed up to class. Thus, the marginal cost of having an additional local or foreign student is minimum.

This system is not for everyone and given that my classes were all in German, it was very challenging. University-level German (vocabulary, idioms, etc) is very different from the one you learn at the Sprachkurs. Most foreign students dropped out and went back home. This is also accentuated by the fact that if you fail an exam 3 times, you are expelled from the university and you are banned from studying that study field for life across all German universities.

Moreover, German universities do not have their own sport facilities and luxurious campuses as their American counterparts. Normally, for sports, there is a shared facility for all local universities and you pay an extra semester ticket to have access. The average German university has old facilities and no luxuries. Thus, the cost base is completely different to universities in the US.

Back then, we were told that Germany offers education to foreigners to foster relations with foreign countries. If we foreigners study in Germany and are shaped the German way, once we go home, not only we will be well qualified, but also we will be keen to establish business relations with German companies.

During my study times, around 2006, they introduced at my university fees for everyone. The idea was not popular and it was not covering the cost of education. The idea did not last long. Some years later it went back to be free for everyone. German universities are very left-leaning and in the German society there is a wide consensus that university education should be free for all.

The CDU and FDP, two political parties on the right spectrum, constantly push the idea of charging foreign students to help finance public education, but the idea has never gotten any type of support in the society.

Good question. I am also interested as well.