robotoloco
Re:Esperanto as an Asian language
on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:15AM (#14847843)
Yes, Anna estas bela is the recommended form. 'est bela' is incorrect.
Re:Esperanto as an Asian language
on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:14AM (#14847833)
English does not fulfill the neutrality ideal of Esperanto, which many people that speak Esperanto think it's very important. Currently, if you are born in an English speak country, you have such a great advantage over everybody else (starting with you don't have to spend lots of money to learn English, and few people attain native speaking levels later in life).
But it is true that the current purpose of Esperanto is more ideal than practical. I study Esperanto because I really like its internal ideals. I study English because I want to eat.
Re:Esperanto as an Asian language
on Tuesday July 25, 2017 @10:06AM (#14847771)
The main reason was neutrality, and respect for the popular language. 'Fixing' the inconsistencies of a language means getting rid of its identity, and culture. You may be able to do that with a dead language, but not with a living one.
As for neutrality, an English or Spanish speaker would always have the advantage, thus the idea that everybody can meet on a ground as even as possible. Esperanto tried to solve that by not belonging to any people, or any nation. It ended up being Eurocentric, but to some extent it does fulfill its neutrality motivation