News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

rlwinm

Re:Elena Programming Language on Friday August 21, 2020 @10:39AM (#24235247)
> Then how does the inviter know, that they can vouch for the invitee?

AFAIK you aren't accountable for your invitees on a day-to-day basis. It just reflects poorly on you if you invite many poorly behaved people - this isn't substantially different from everyday life.

> Perhaps no one there knows me. Why would anyone vouch for someone they don't know?

Some people do invite everyone who asks. They can have their invite rights disabled or in extreme cases be banned from the site. This is relatively rare.

You can see examples of this at https://lobste.rs/moderations?moderator=%28All%29&what%5Buse....

> Wouldn't that make vouching a useless hurdle?

Lobste.rs has a small audience and 3 moderators. The moderation is also much more active than HN - moderators will send private warnings, delete off-topic posts, etc. Moderator actions are publicly visible at https://lobste.rs/moderations. Vouching raises the barrier to entry and allows the moderators to keep up with the workload.

> For instance, there's a restriction at my workplace (not a software company, a regular old industry fortune 500) which prevents git installs from pushing to any non corporate GitHub repo from our work machines.

Someone has to say it.

I’ll admit to accidentally pushing some of my employer’s code to GitHub.

The code was a fork of one of my GitHub repositories and I pushed to the wrong remote. I deleted the resulting commits afterwards and no PII was leaked but it’s a valid concern for employers.

Re:Web browsers need to stop. Enough is enough on Friday August 14, 2020 @03:19PM (#24162119)
Do you want to call people out or change their behavior?

Public shaming may be successful at the former but often fails at the latter. If anything it often causes people to reinforce a position they might have otherwise conceded. The other negative effects of shaming are well discussed in the Jon Ronson book So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed.

If you work on AMP, for example, it’s easy to dismiss Drew’s rant as that of a fanatic. Many people don’t think their work is unethical or immoral.

It’s much harder to dismiss a reasoned argument that acknowledges the benefits of AMP and gives examples of the deleterious effects of AMP.

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) on Friday August 14, 2020 @02:15PM (#24161318)
I agree that the post you linked to was downvoted unfairly.

Many of his subsequent posts have been fairly downvoted.

I think some of his downvotes are from people who have interacted with him elsewhere. His reply to one of my comments is why I’m using this alternate account.

His recent post about pkg.go.dev misrepresented the facts.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24023998

He frequently takes an absolutist stance, often assumes negative intent, and is at best abrasive.

Here are some examples:

https://github.com/freeCodeCamp/mail-for-good/issues/357

https://github.com/kisslinux/repo/issues/100

> I would like to add, I use much of ddevaults software on a daily basis, and have found it to be some of the absolute best I've ever used. As such, I tend to give what he says at least a moment of thought.

It’s your call but I would be hesitant to use anything by him. How would he respond if I report a bug or open a feature request?

Re:I don't trust Signal (2018) on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:20AM (#24132913)
Do you have any examples of well-written and thoughtful comments by ddevault that were downvoted?

Many of the comments I see from him violate the guidelines at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Many of his blog posts (4 out of the last 5 submissions from drewdevault.com) are ill-informed and angry rants about a technology or company. These discussions generate a lot of heat but little light; it’s not surprising that they are downvoted.