riptheworld
You are arguing that decentralization creates immutability. Decentralization has nothing to do with hashing.
If you are concerned with changing an NFT's content or debating philosophically about whether that should be allowed, I don't have an opinion. I don't own NFTs, nor am I convinced they will stick around. My point is that the NFT ecosystem will likely evolve to create technical solutions solving many of the problems mentioned in the article.
There's nothing in the Bitcoin protocol that explicitly prevents a longer and valid chain from being accepted. Forks happen every day where miners are competing to construct the longest accepted chain on the network (it's part of the protocol).
However, the difficulty in maliciously changing previous blocks in the Bitcoin blockchain is explicitly parameterized by the security level of the PoW mechanism. There are undergrad CS courses where this analysis is probably a homework problem.
In PoS, immutability is baked into the protocol since the block selection algorithm doesn't explicitly cause forking as it does in PoW based blockchains.
Decentralization creates trust that newly added blocks contain valid transactions, not to ensure that previous blocks don’t change. This is why the finality times of Bitcoin are strictly worse than the finality times of Algorand, or other PoS blockchains. Not because one network is more decentralized than the other, but because Bitcoin’s immutability property is hamstringed by the PoW security level.
EDIT: Anticipating your response requesting citations - here are the lecture notes from the "Foundations of Blockchain Systems" course at the University of Washington, Seattle [1]. From section 3.2, I quote:
"One property of the blockchain is immutability. This means that the chain cannot be changed given the last block in the chain. This is because it is difficult to find a hash of x that is equal to hash of y in computationally feasible time (collision-resistance). We add the qualifier “given the last block” because if we disagree on which is the last block, we may have problems. With distributed mining, there is a possibility of simultaneous mining, however these ties should be resolved quickly with proper tuning of parameters. Therefore, although we may not agree on the last block all of the time, all blocks will lead back to the genesis, starting block, and the large majority of the chain will be in agreement."
[1] https://ece595uwseattle.github.io/Scribe_notes_Lecture_3.pdf
You are incorrect. The proof of work mechanism is central to ensuring the immutability of the blockchain.
As a concrete example, suppose there are N blocks in the blockchain, and I want to change a transaction in the (N - 2) block. Obviously, this will change the hash of the (N - 1) and N-th blocks, so the decentralized network will not accept this arbitrary change.
However, if I can produce four PoWs corresponding to the new (N - 2), (N - 1), N, and (N + 1)th blocks, then I can convince the network to accept. Of course, I have to produce these four PoWs before the honest users on the network mine the next block at index (N + 1). This is extremely difficult by design. In theory, you would need the majority of the network’s computing power to carry out this attack.
In other words, the security level of the proof of work is directly related to the difficulty in modifying the blockchain.
For example, rather than only storing a URL that points to the content, perhaps the token could also include a cryptographic hash of the original content? In the case of link rot, the owner could still provide evidence of ownership on the original content by proving that it hashes to the stored value.
There are probably better solutions as well (others have mentioned IPFS).
In some sense, we would be back to having banks with the exception that the bank now exists solely as an investment vehicle.
I guess I’m struggling to see what barriers prevent crypto currencies from being used in traditional financing?
1.) decrease mining difficulty, i.e., the amount of hashing required to produce a valid proof-of-work on average. This impacts the security of the network.
2.) increase the block size so you can fit more transactions into a single block. This negatively impacts network latency (and therefore scalability, as it increases the burden of propagating messages across the network).
To your question on Algorand: yes, new consensus participants can quickly and easily sync with the current state of the blockchain through fast catch-up [1], without any meaningful security degradation [2].
> It would work the same way PayPal works with USD. Bitcoin payments simply don't need to happen on the blockchain. Similarly, I can buy gold in my brokerage account without any actual gold moving between warehouses.
This is a terrible idea.
This is not to say that the Lightning Network doesn't significantly improve the usability of Bitcoin as a currency. But it does so at the expense of security. A much better approach is to use a layer 1 solution that achieves scalability, security, and decentralization by default.
The Algorand cryptocurrency achieves thousands of transactions per second and very fast finality times (i.e., the time it takes to ensure that blocks no longer change). These are arguably the two most important performance metrics in terms of scalability.
In terms of security, I would argue that Algorand’s consensus protocol (Pure Proof of Stake) is MORE robust than Bitcoin and Ethereum. Mechanisms like Proof of Work are great at providing computational security guarantees, but really fail to address network based attacks [1](e.g., partitioning the Bitcoin network to influence who hears about which transactions and blocks).
[1]https://allquantor.at/blockchainbib/pdf/tran2020stealthier.p...
Of course proof of stake can be decentralized! I think what you mean is that it's not clear whether a widely adopted PoS based blockchain will end up centralizing power in the hands of a few whales. This is a legitimate concern; however, this threat is no different than the threat of centralization of computing power in Bitcoin. In Bitcoin, this isn't even a threat, it’s a reality!
I'll say it again: Bitcoin and Ethereum are not great currencies. There are altcoins that have far surpassed both of them in terms of achieving security, scalability, and decentralization simultaneously.
Bitcoin and Ethereum are pretty terrible currencies. Proof-of-work is a foundational idea in cryptography, but it’s much better suited for preventing mass email spam than it is as a consensus mechanism.
Not to mention how the cryptocurrency space is crowded with useless AltCoins. Unless you’re an expert in the space, its so hard to distinguish from true innovation and dummies just trying to get a piece of the pie. As a result, you have millions of people pushing things like Dogecoin and Shiba, and it ends up hurting real people.
The way I see it is this: a useful cryptocurrency needs 3 things:
(1) Security (2) Scalability (3) Decentralization
Almost all mainstream crypto fails at (2) miserably, and as a result end up failing at (3). High transaction fees, volatility, low throughput, and energy-intensive participation costs are all barriers to achieving actual utility.
Private communication is essential for freedom of speech. I may not speak freely with my friends or family if I believe that those conversations are easily accessible by the government. It's not that these conversations are inherently bad either; rather, I believe that people have a tendency to self-censor themselves depending on their audience. When the audience consists of an entity that has overwhelming influence on your life, I believe the potential for self-censorship is enormous.
Historically, many of the world’s greatest ideas were first discussed in private. Bold ideas were discussed in discreet locations, free from the threat of eavesdroppers out of fear of government recourse. Nowadays, technology has enabled people to communicate instantaneously with one another from thousands of miles away. Encryption enhances that capability by further allowing that communication to be private, fostering freedom of speech and the discussion of new ideas. It is really quite amazing when you think about it!