processcontrol
Re:US court rules masking IP address to access blocked Website violate...
on Thursday August 22, 2013 @01:33PM (#6258577)
Having a website is not at all like 'shouting on a public square' and is exactly like having a bar open to the public.
Craigslist told a patron they couldn't come in any more. The patron put on a fake mustache and tried to come in the back door.
Would you support someone scraping a blog to repost it elsewhere? Do you support crawlers that don't respect robots.txt? I don't see a problem with Craigslist saying 'No, you can't scrape our users content to post on your website'.
The exact details of which laws and how the court case went may not be correct, but at a theoretical level the website as open-to-public bar/store/etc is a perfectly valid analogy.