News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

porfirio

Re:Yelp Files For $100 Million IPO on Thursday November 17, 2011 @03:38PM (#3249106)
Does this mean self-absorbed hipsters cum wannabe food critics are worth something? The end is near.

Yelp does a great service though. But half the reviewers are just intolerable attention whores. Found this hilarious explication: http://www.freddiew.com/2009/05/22/yelp-is-great-i-just-hate...

The other sites, like City Search and Google reviews, don't attract this element, probably because they don't allow for elaborate "profiles" and don't cultivate a "community."

I noticed something similar, though not as a programmer.

I tested videogames one summer, where it was my job to locate and report bugs. It was soon apparent that there was huge variation in productivity: some people submitted more and better bugs, in better written reports, than others.

Most people were hired as independent contractors through an outside company. A select few would be hired by the actual game company, and kept on through the season. Was it the most productive who were kept on? No. It was the people who put in the most overtime hours, and made themselves available when the company asked.

Call me an ignorant youth, but it seemed like, if they wanted to, they could raise salaries, fire the bottom X%, and hire some more talented QA testers, and still come out ahead.

Cook's explanation doesn't really explain this scenario, but I have a feeling the answer is similar, for both the QA tester and the programmer.

My theory: management simply doesn't care, and doesn't need to. If you were to walk out, they could easily get someone else at the exact same pay-grade. It's only when your value to the company is crystal clear, and you are clearly better than the competition, and that there's a viable threat that you will leave somewhere else and actually get better pay, that a company will pay you accordingly.

After all, economics doesn't say you get paid what you're worth. It says you get paid the market clearing wage. You might be creating $200 of value per hour for your employer, but if there are tons of people ready to work for $10 an hour and are just as productive, then you will get paid $10 an hour.

This is more conjecture, but I think for things to change, for people to be paid according to their productivity, two critical pieces of information are essential:

1. Exactly how productive you are, relative to your peers. 2. Exactly how much people of varying abilities make.

The problem is, for #1, the metrics are bad if at all existent. For #2, there's a huge taboo against telling people what you make, which ultimately helps employers keep wages lower.

I think my QA testing situation would have been different if say, the men in charge took some pride in it, and only hired great testers. They didn't, they were just filling slots, so the QA on the QA testers themselves was pretty shoddy.

Re:A Better Way To Travel on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:31PM (#3240874)
"Featured Stops Starbucks (Coffee Shop) In-N-Out Burger (Burgers) Chevron (Gas Station / Garage) McDonald's (Fast Food) Jack in the Box (Fast Food) Los Pinos Mexican Restaurant (Mexican) Six Flags Magic Mountain (Theme Park) Westfield Valencia Town Center (Mall) Chick-fil-A (Fast Food) Porto's Bakery & Cafe (Bakery) Universal Studios Hollywood (Theme Park) IKEA (Furniture / Home)"

First page of results. LA to SF. Next page includes "IN THE MIDDLE OF F#%~*?¥! NOWHERE!!! (Farm)"

Re:High IQ linked to drug use on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:13PM (#3239644)
Novel claims require evidence.

Here is another link: http://discovermagazine.com/2005/oct/sex

There are more genes related to intelligence on the X chromosome than on just the X and Y chromosomes. There are still 22 other pairs of chromosomes, which in offspring, are a mishmash of the father and mother's chromosomes. Genes on these chromosomes have been experimentally linked with intelligence (eg, http://genepi.qimr.edu.au/contents/p/staff/CV453.pdf)

Plus, there are sex differences in intelligence; there are more male dullards and geniuses. Men score higher on visuospatial ability, and women on verbal ability. Given that these are distinctly sex related, their genesis lies in differences between the X and Y chromosomes.

Re:High IQ linked to drug use on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:31PM (#3239120)
This article doesn't tell us what we think it does.

In America, the relationship between drug use and high IQ is small or non-existent: http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-scientific-fundament...

(Someone else linked this earlier)

Despite the UK being very similar to the US, on a global scale, the relationship between IQ and drug use is not the same across the herring pond. There are relationships between IQ and social indicators that are consistent across time and nations, and this isn't one of those. Whatever is causing this relationship in Britain is cultural - I doubt it's a feature of high intelligence, rather than just Brits who have high IQ.

Re:High IQ linked to drug use on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @11:06AM (#3238665)
A Scottish study found that IQ is stable, over a 66 year period. http://homepages.ed.ac.uk/ijdeary/papers/SMS32_98.pdf

Also, just because one can game the test, or make its result less accurate, it doesn't mean the population level data is much less accurate. I'm reminded of the Body Mass Index - men, by strength training, can put on lots of muscle mass and become classified as "overweight" or even (rarely) "obese" without being fat. But the fact is that most "overweight" men are in fact fat, and not muscular. The fact that a test for an individual can have reduced or zero validity, does not necessarily threaten the validity for the overall population.

If everyone were to start gaming the tests, things might be different. Then again, being able to game the test might be a highly IQ dependent task, so the IQ test remains an IQ test.

Re:High IQ linked to drug use on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:57AM (#3238627)
"IQ is heritable, but the catch is that it may, in fact, only be heritable through the mother's half of the genes contributed to the child [1]."

Do you have a source for this that isn't, um, from the Simpsons? Geneticists have an equation for estimating the response to selection, the change in IQ from parent to offspring, and it uses an average of both parents' IQ. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability#Response_to_Select... for the equation.

IQ is somewhat more malleable initially, but it seems to converge on a point set by one's genetics, by adulthood. The APA estimated heritability in childhood at .45 and .75 by adulthood.

Re:High IQ linked to drug use on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:38AM (#3237676)
"IQ is also correlated with revenue (probably because that's what it actually measures: socio-economic class)"

False. Charles Murray compared brothers of the same household of different intelligence levels, and found significant disparities in income.

http://www.eugenics.net/papers/murray.html (article originally appeared in The Telegraph)

It's more accurate to say socioeconomic class measures IQ, rather than the other way around. To oversimplify, high IQ people are more productive, IQ at adulthood is heritable to a great extent (~80% of variation in IQ is due to genetic variation), so 1 + 1 = rich families have higher IQ children. Imagine if people were paid based on how tall they are, and replace IQ with height, and it'd be the same -> Tall parents + high heritability for height -> rich families have taller offspring. People don't recognize this with regards to IQ because they ultimately don't believe IQ is highly heritable, which it is.

Links:

IQ and productivity: http://www.onetest.com.au/awms/Upload/documents/whitepapers/...

IQ and heritability: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ (first paragraph)

Re:High IQ linked to drug use on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:21AM (#3237641)
I know a fair amount about IQ, having studied it a bit, and I'm surprised. IQ correlates pretty strongly, with law abiding behavior, at the very least, not going to jail. High IQ people are less socially dysfunctional than average and low IQ people, eg see the table here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bell_Curve

As for the sex difference between men and women of high IQ, fewer women in general do drugs, so it's easier for high IQ women to rack up a higher multiple of drug use over their average IQ female counterparts.

I looked at the Psychology Today/Kanazawa link, and it says that the relationship is insignificant in America. I.e., the relationship between childhood IQ and drug use is a British phenomenon. Maybe the intelligent are more decadent in Britain? If Kanazawa represents the data accurately, this whole IQ-drugs relationship is BS, in the American setting. Bye bye grand social theorizing.