News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

oxplot

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @10:00AM (#33866464)
From the first link:

> The Model 3 sedan was being described on Tesla’s Korean website claiming 'can drive more than 528 km on a single charge'. However, on its US website, Tesla describes Model 3's performance as "Go anywhere with "up to" 358 miles of estimated range on a single charge." 358 miles equates to about 576 kms, and much less than what Tesla claimed in South Korean markets. After local media raised the issue and the regulator stepped in, Tesla changed the range from ‘more than’ to a ‘maximum’ 528 kilometres.

What??!! 576km is not much less than 528km, it's more! So Tesla was in fact correctly indicating that the range is more than 528km, because it is! Either this is awful reporting or there is a mistake in there. Also saying "can drive more than" instead of "up to" isn't necessarily an exaggeration, it may simply be a mistake in wording of the website. I give them the benefit of doubt here because I've never seen Tesla advertise range like that. It's often a single number with a testing methodology suffix (like EPA). There is no "up to" or the like qualifiers.

As for the second link, super interesting content. But EPA has certified the range and all other manufacturers are free to do what Tesla does to make their range more appealing. Nothing fishy going on here as far as I'm concerned. Exaggerating range in context of a certification program is moot (unless you're cheating and Tesla is clearly not, according to this article).

> A friend of mine paid the $10k as a "line jumping fee" to get his car 4 months earlier, and I assume that most informed buyers treat the FSD package the same.

Really? You thought this was a compelling example?!!! Have you never bought an "as-is" item from a shop which was on display. You pay cheaper but you can't bring it back for refund if you change your mind. This is common practice in every industry. You wanna be treated differently, you give up some perks.

People who buy FSD package as a way to jump the queue aren't buying FSD, they're buying time and as such doubt they will care about functionality of FSD.

I was referring to people who buy FSD for its current and future capabilities.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:39AM (#33866197)
Some people are intimidated by success of others, especially if they don't have much going on in their own lives. And some people get excited and motivated by it and want to do more. Those would be the caliber of people who end up working at Tesla or SpaceX or Apple, etc and join the fun.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:35AM (#33866149)
> I have a nice/fun/convenient commuter car that hasn't needed any maintenance and the trade in is higher than I paid for it. Is it for everyone? Is it for everyone? No. But that doesn't mean there is a void in value.

I'm sure you have reasons for downplaying this, but I would follow this with "and told them, in your face losers", or something to that effect.

Saying "saving money and hassle" isn't for everyone is suspicious to say the least. Why wouldn't it be for everyone?

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:28AM (#33866056)
> you can never make personal transport as cheap as public transport, because personal transport will always carry fewer passengers per ride.

Oh man, another "never" statement. An autonomous car that doesn't have a driver, doesn't need to take breaks to eat or sleep, that doesn't need to be parked, can in fact become cheaper than public transport. I invite you to do some research on that.

> And people really want to ride in nice, clean, custom cars, plus they really don't want to ride with other people most of the time.

That's exactly my point, and why in presence of a price competitive option such as a self driving taxi, no one would want to catch a bus or a train with many people and dirty seats.

> autonomous driving could be 50 years into the future

Not if you're in the know. It's far closer, but I'm not arguing for that. Wait and see.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:18AM (#33865923)
You are aware that manufactures face penalties for lying and deception, right? I can't recall Tesla ever being fined for misleading marketing, ever.

> Tesla semi was production ready in 2020

I guess you've never missed a deadline. That's not lying. It's miscalculation.

> and was more efficient than train

A Semi convoy is expected to be cheaper than a train and they re-iterated that in the latest event. No evidence to the contrary so far.

> And whatever other lies musk said back then.

Promised 500 miles. Delivered 500 miles. Turned the impossible (according to pretty much everyone, from Bill Gates, to CEO of truck making companies who joked that Tesla Semi will be breaking laws of physics) into late. Still not lying.

> Musk is prolific deceiver, I dont trust a single thing coming out of his mouth nor his websites.

He doesn't have websites. He has companies that have websites.

> Tesla cars are notorious for its expensive repairs. Its a huge cost and risk switching to it.

Is that why Hertz, that puts the most number of miles on a passenger vehicle has ordered 100000 Teslas, 20% of its global fleet, because it loves to waste money on cost of repair?

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @09:07AM (#33865802)
> Calling it's driver assist Autopilot, calling its software FSD, repeatedly saying "FSD is coming next year" is overpromising, misleading marketing and lying

OK, finally an actual example and the one I expected.

TL;DR is that if Tesla was in fact doing anything the regulators found to be hurting the customers, they would be forcing Tesla to make changes (and they have re FSD in some minor ways). It's fun to make a big deal about nothing but no one is buying FSD and thinking, Tesla robbed me $10K. They get it, play with it, it doesn't do what they promised, they can get a refund for the FSD package, and even a full refund for the entire car. People tend to keep their Teslas, so that's a non issue.

Majority of people don't buy Teslas for promise of FSD (in fact, most don't even believe it). They buy it because right now, it's a great car. As far as delivering great cars is concerned (which is the vast majority of cases), Tesla has delivered time and again.

Also, Tesla has never lied about FSD, only missing deadlines. If anything, their progress has shown anything but any attempt to lie to customers. They are moving as fast as they can and no one in the industry comes close.

I'll be happy to see, for once, someone talk about misleading marketing about anything but FSD. You can take FSD away any day and it won't make a blip of difference to Tesla's sales or margins.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @08:47AM (#33865556)
OMG! So sorry to hear that. That's awful! :( but thanks for sticking with it.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @08:38AM (#33865431)
> the infrastructure likely makes heavy use of batteries to avoid stressing out local substations and avoid abusing grid peaking

From Tesla's presentation, it looks like that.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @08:08AM (#33865095)
> Who has the financial incentive to build charging stations? Both out and back and point to point operators will build charging infrastructure at their own hubs/terminals and use them for themselves.

Don't forget that Tesla will probably end up building the most number of chargers over time. Charging is its own business with its own margins (e.g. Supercharger network). In other words, it's a source of net income for Tesla so as they build more trucks, they'll build more chargers as they've done to date with passenger cars and Superchargers.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @08:03AM (#33865056)
> Everyone has caught up

They are caught up when they start outselling Tesla (or heck become available so one can actually buy one).

Great cars (which I don't think Hyundai/Kia are by any stretch of imagination, from piss-poor software to poor charging infrastructure, but let's discount this for now) can exist at great prices all they want, but if I can't get my hand on one and the 500 or so that show up once every few month get gobbled up in seconds, they practically do not exist at all.

And mind you, the disparity in production is not gonna go away any time soon. They're all limited by battery production and unless they make their own batteries, Tesla has long been in the line to buy batteries from anywhere they possibly can, as much as they can. They don't screw around.

BYD is far more of a competitor to Tesla than Kia/Hyandai have been to date.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:51AM (#33864950)
It's called aiming high!
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:49AM (#33864930)
Yes - doing math and rational reasoning is hard. Pasting irrelevant links to Wikipedia, super easy.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:44AM (#33864867)
Did a quick search. Diesel Semis' curb weight ranges b/w 10000lbs-25000lbs. The 10000lbs one may not be comparable in performance/range to Tesla Semi so keep that in mind.

Tesla Semi based on the estimate in the article, is about 27000lbs.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:37AM (#33864788)
> since as a general rule rail is cheaper than trucks

That's not the way to approach claims that a new tech/product is disruptive. General rules may not (and usually do not) apply.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:34AM (#33864771)
> I hope they don't lobby against mass transit (of goods and people). But they probably will, making things worse for all us.

People in general are not fond of the experience of mass transit. They only do it because it's either (or all):

- cheap (no parking fees, car purchase/maintenance)

- less hassle (no need to find parking in busy areas and no need to have all attention to driving)

If personal transport can be made cheaper, less hassle and hands-free (all of which is possible by autonomous vehicles), then people will vote with their pennies and no lobbying will be required by Tesla.

How will this be worse?

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:22AM (#33864652)
I agree - trains make more sense than running overhead wires over highways.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:19AM (#33864626)
Sorry I should have been more specific. I'm referring to economics from the viewpoint of the business operating a fleet. Given almost all business do not hold back from whatever incentive and subsidies are available to them, it's fairly reasonable boundary to confine the comparison to.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:15AM (#33864578)
> Why not ?

As in, we run out of fossil fuels (or it gets prohibitively expensive) and your truck becomes brick because its internal battery and electric drivetrain is pretty much useless without the ICE part.

Solar, wind and thermal are practically unlimited for duration of the planet's existence.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @07:10AM (#33864524)
No obstacles to do the math yourself!
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:51AM (#33864365)
What a disingenuous analogy to make, between Tesla that has delivered time and time again and surpassed expectations, led the market for the past 10 years and continues to outsell all of its century old competitors, with Theranos which burnt investor money and never produced a working machine, ever.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:46AM (#33864315)
I don't know what your situation is, but here's mine:

Got a Model 3 back in 2020. The service I've had to get done to date has been what's in the user manual: tire rotation, cabin air filter replacement and brake fluid check. That's it! No down time other than the few hours per service visit (for which they paid me equivalent of $50 USD to travel from and to the service center on each visit).

And I've used 90% Superchargers to charge and despite that, saved a lot on gas.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:41AM (#33864285)
Oh, I was just repeating what pifm_guy said above and their expectations from Tesla. I was just tagging along in the fantasy. :D
Re:Tesla's electric Semi faces a long, slow, uphill climb on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:27AM (#33864178)
> Yes, but: Tesla omitted crucial information, including the truck's empty weight — an important consideration for measuring its efficiency. A Tesla Semi "fully loaded" with Doritos can go farther than a truck packed with cases of Pepsi. "Not very impressive — moving a cargo of chips (average weight per pack 52 grams) cannot in any way be said to be definitive proof of concept," said Oliver Dixon, senior analyst at consultancy Guidehouse, per Reuters.

Garbage. Tesla published uncut video of its Semi carrying at least 44000lbs worth of concrete blocks 500 miles going up and down 6 degree grade, in traffic and ending up on the same elevation as the starting point, with charge left in the battery. Pack of doritors my ass.

EDIT: oh and thanks for mentioning Reuters — they published news about Musk and Cook fued days after they had settled their conflict.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:14AM (#33864083)
Not sure what you're implying with this. Specs have remained exactly the same and now, they've actually delivered on the spec they advertised in 2017.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:11AM (#33864065)
It's all about economics. Whatever's cheaper wins. To that end, Tesla has mentioned in their presentations that a Tesla Semi convoy of only 3 trucks can be cheaper than a train for the same load.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @06:08AM (#33864041)
> I always assumed the future of electric trucking would involve little battery trailers that could be quickly swapped out on a rolling basis by fleets of trucks.

Maybe the future, but right now, I suspect the battery energy density is not forgiving enough for the battery to just be a carry load. Increasingly, the battery module is part of the structure of the vehicle and further works as weight to increase traction close to the drivetrain. There is also a lot of nitty-gritty details to do with safety, efficiency and cooling that makes moving the battery away from the Semi itself not a viable option ATM.

Also keep in mind that at least for consumer cars, Tesla did try battery swap stations but nobody seemed to show any interest so they canned it.

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @05:49AM (#33863909)
Sounds like a case of needing to read up on history of innovation and how you don't get overnight mass adoption. I suggest picking up a book on advent of internal combustion engine and the five decades that followed.
Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @04:42AM (#33863424)
The problem with hybrid vehicles in general is that they still rely on fossil fuels to some extent, so they're not a truly sustainable solution. And they have all the maintenance and reliability baggage of their fully ICE counterparts, something BEVs do away with.

The time and money being spent on developing hybrid technology could be better spent on making fully electric vehicles more affordable and accessible.

EDIT: and keep in mind, trucks are purchased with a long service life in mind (decades)

Re:Tesla Semi, a Deep Dive on Monday December 05, 2022 @04:28AM (#33863318)
Intrigued so did a bunch of searches for commercial machines and can't find any mention of "fix it or take it back and pay me for my time" terms anywhere.

Care to share one?

Older »