operae

If you use the data to train a commercial model and distribute it how is that not infringement?

If I use a reversed Jay-Z sample in my music, I will still get sued. This is just a couple of orders of magnitude higher abstraction.

"I think that with respect to content that is already on the open web, the social contract of that content since the 1990s has been it is fair use"

This argument cannot possibly hold in any court. This has not been the 'contract'. I cannot reproduce the content of a newspapers online outlet, I cannot reproduce the art of another artist on Instagram, I cannot reproduce someones Youtube video without permission. This same thing sparked the whole fair-use debate some years ago.

The exceptions to these rules have always existed in limbos of regulatory grey areas and are being discussed for decades now.

This guy is still living in the Napster-era apparently and the amount of gaslighting Microsoft, OpenAI, Google etc. perform right now to freeload on data is presumptuous.

All of these AI Wrapper companies are getting pushed out of the market by big tech sooner or later. Those blue oceans are actually red as fuck.