News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

ntstatusquo

Nothing wrong with using AI for software development, but your product landing page being chock full of LLM-isms is an honest signal about how much care was put into this project.

Also, it somehow, bafflingly, against all odds, manages to use 60% more memory and 3x as much CPU as the underwhelming XAML task manager that comes with windows. How about we figure out how to use fewer resources, rather than way more resources, than the already unreasonably inefficient thing that Microsoft ships?

Also, I find it funny that this TMOG thing seems to apply a special rule such that its own process does not appear in the dashboards by default.

My one data point is that Casey’s handmade hero series, and his immediate mode gui video from way back in 2005, are what introduced me and some friends to an entirely new way to build graphical user interfaces, and I do feel a great appreciation for that. Guys like Ryan Fleury (of RadDbg) and Vjekoslav Krajacic of Filepilot similarly credit Casey with their “radicalization” :) To your point though, it was less about specific technical knowledge conveyed by these videos and more about him evangelizing a high level approach that many folks otherwise wouldn’t have considered
True, the project where I used the approach above was a TUI, so windows terminal sort of eats the impact of stuff like user32 and dwrite for you.

One trick I know of to make user32 a bit more lightweight is to call ImmDisableIme prior to creating your first window. This disables a lot of the TSF integration, which is notably quite slow. Not sure if it impacts memory footprint but worth a try. It of course does what the name says and disables IME support, so not a viable option if you have users who need IME

You can get a sub 20kb executable with C in MSVC and no weird tricks, i.e. just setting a particular combination of compiler/linker flags, like /NODEFAULTIB, /MERGE, /FILEALIGN:512 etc. Small enough that it's basically nothing, downloads in a couple of seconds over 56k dialup, and you get to use normal tooling. This is the compromise that makes the most sense to me, for products you're actually shipping. If you want to try out the nocrt approach, honestly the LLMs do a fine job of writing you some replacements for the parts of the crt that you likely want i.e. memcpy/memcmp/strlen helpers, with x64/arm64 SIMD and all.

Set /HEAP:4096,4096 and /STACK:65536,4096, write yourself a simple 100 line growable arena implementation, use that, avoid the heap entirely. Very quick and easy way to get a real windows program up and running that uses about 500kb of commit at baseline.

You end up with only ntdll.dll, kernelbase.dll, and kernel32.dll loaded. Trying to eliminate any of these becomes pretty painful and you venture into the territory of weird tricks that are expensive to maintain.

Dave's approach is a fun exercise though.

Re:Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone on Thursday August 20, 2026 @01:04PM (#49377288)
I can guarantee you that Raymond had zero input on any of these decisions. He values fundamentals, quality, and customer satisfaction more than anybody. But ultimately, is just an "individual contributor" engineer down in the trenches following orders. He probably feels the same way you do about this stuff. The real question for me is, why does a famous person like him, with so many options open to him about where he works and what he works on, continue slogging away in Redmond.

My best guess is that he has devoted most of his working life to Windows, and it would be painful give up on it. He has lived through many dark periods, i.e. ME, Vista, Windows 8, and is probably optimistic about the pendulum swinging back towards quality/fundamentals eventually.

Re:Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone on Thursday August 20, 2026 @12:59PM (#49377231)
"tell me you're a rust programmer without telling me you're a rust programmer"
Re:Windows brings out the Rorschach test in everyone on Thursday August 20, 2026 @12:53PM (#49377146)
My personal favorite is the classic "Walls and Ladders" post about topmost windows: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20110310-00/?p=11...

Raymond's work often uses analogies to everyday, real life situations to make the technical stuff more relatable. Sometimes, these end up being bizarre and even nightmarish. It's like a glimpse into some alternate world where the denizens are adversarial, hyper pedantic, scheming, criminally insane, or just plain stupid.

"Sometimes I’m in a hurry, and I want to make sure I am the next person to get served at the deli counter. To do this, I find whoever has the lowest number, knock them unconscious, and steal their ticket. But sometimes somebody else comes in who’s also in a hurry. That person knocks me unconscious and steals my ticket. My plan is to set my watch alarm to wake me up periodically, and each time it wakes me up, I find the person with the lowest number, knock them unconscious, and steal their ticket. Is there a better way?"

"This is like asking for a cheeseburger and then trying to peel every last bit of cheese off the patty to turn it into a plain hamburger."

"This is like driving up to a bridge, seeing a 'Bridge out of order' sign, then getting out of your car, moving the sign, driving onto the bridge, falling into the river, and then complaining to the car manufacturer that their car doesn’t work."

"This is like calling the natural gas utility company’s emergency number to report a major gas leak in your house. The gas company sends a technician over, and they can’t find any leak. They ask how you came to suspect that there’s a gas leak, and you tell them, 'Oh, I didn’t smell anything. I called you because I’m hoping to learn more about how to recognize the smell of gas. Do you have any tips?'"

"This is like 'I have this cupboard full of rubbish, so I will solve that by nailing the doors shut'"

"It’s like asking, 'What happens to the phrase 1 cup sugar when I eat my cookies?' The phrase 1 cup sugar was part of the instructions for making the cookies"