News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

nat4ever

Re:The trolley problem (Relevant to autopilot mode in cars) on Saturday November 19, 2016 @10:33AM (#12993875)
Thinking it through, a person kind of develops a sense that all of the interesting things, in this branch of thought experiments, tend to shake out, postmortem.

In the heat of the moment, what seems like a plausible bargain threatens to reveal grotesque details amid the wreckage.

So, the trolley problem itself usually becomes most interesting when inspecting the identities of any casualties. e.g. What about famous people? What about small children?

In this case, the scenario becomes threatening with the possibility of proving that the condemned was sacrificed only to placate mob rule. e.g. What if the real criminal is found later, somehow?

Acting with a tendency to ignore the postmortem consequences is probably how a machine will operate. They don't have reputation. They don't consult emotion to inform their decisions.

A machine might not question which teddy bear was the most favorite teddy bear, when organizing a garage sale.

Of course, I'm being a little cheeky, but ah, my sentiment of digging a moat around a house with an unlocked door is an idea I'll always keep in my back pocket, and show no hesitation in applying a ridiculous solution to a ridiculous problem.

Obscurity and inscrutability certainly will never supplant the Objective Ideological Truth that "Security" tries to be, but it's often useful as a source of leverage when all other leverage would be denied to you.

You could never ever claim to endorse obscurity for its own sake during a daily stand-up or a conference call, because people woud rip you to shreds for any number of valid reasons, but when push comes to shove, and you find yourself on the losing side of someone else's moral hazard, being able to throw a smoke screen up, where a brick wall would be preferred, is sometimes all you can do.

Yes. Yes. Yes.

An internet that requires devices to be publicly exposed to the entire internet, and directly addressable at all times, is not an internet I want to participate in.

You WILL negotiate a firewall, before learning anything about the devices I use.

ESPECIALLY if I am prevented from knowing their internals, whether by willful disclosure or unlawful reverse engineering.

I control The Spice.

I control the universe.