moosecombinator
moosecombinator on Hacker News
Re:Deprecating the PCOMMIT Instruction
on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:28AM (#12505492)
Ouch -- accused of marketing speak. That one stings.
I had been using the term "power-fail safe domain" to talk about the line a store crosses where it is then persistent in the face of power failures. But that led people to think power failure was the only event considered so we started saying "persistence domain." I'm certainly open to suggestions on terminology.
Re:Deprecating the PCOMMIT Instruction
on Thursday September 15, 2016 @08:24AM (#12505473)
Author here. The PCOMMIT encoding you mention produces an undefined opcode fault on all existing CPUs (written as #UD in the specs). Since no CPU has shipped supporting PCOMMIT, this gives us high confidence that no code containing PCOMMIT is currently in-use or it would be producing #UD faults. Since the need for PCOMMIT has gone away, that fact allowed us to remove the instruction before it created legacy code we'd be signed up to support forever.
I love your examples of other removals -- didn't know about those.