News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

lokshin

Re:iPhone vs. Droid GPS signal quality on Sunday July 18, 2010 @08:46PM (#1527254)
I used Run Keeper for the iPhone and it gave the same results as MotionX, which is why I continued using just one of them to collect data (and then write up the blog post). There's nothing to say, though, that both programs may just be crap...
Re:iPhone vs. Droid GPS signal quality on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:53PM (#1526982)
True GPS was definitely turned on. Motion X doesn't tell you how many satellites it's tracking, but handy runner was tracking 6 at the time (iPhone4 vs N1), and MotionX was showing an acquired signal so it must have been tracking at least three. I also tried to hold the phone as loosely as possible (although I doubt this made a difference).

There is a comment above on Apple choosing a lower sampling rate in exchange for better battery life. I think this is probably right on. Most users will only be using the GPS to mark driving directions or to record something like running. In these cases the GPS is definitely good enough (you're just hugging streets anyway). Unfortunately, it's not good enough for me : ).

I would definitely be more than willing to run more tests or try different programs if people throw out ideas.