News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

lkhliutier34

Re:The Rise of the Architectural Cult on Monday December 30, 2019 @07:44PM (#21918071)
Article makes your point too:

> But architecture is very different from other forms of art: people who hate Beethoven aren’t obligated to listen to it from 9-5 every weekday, and people who hate the Transformers series aren’t obligated to watch it every night before bed. The physical environment in which we live and work, however, is ubiquitous and inescapable; when it comes to architecture, it is nigh-impossible for people to simply avoid the things they hate and seek out the things they like.

Re:The Rise of the Architectural Cult on Monday December 30, 2019 @07:13PM (#21917879)
Basically modern architects are taught in school that any form of symmetry or traditional decoration is un-authentic and un-aceptable. This is why you can't find two aligned windows in a modern "signature" building.

> This paranoid revulsion against classical aesthetics was not so much a school of thought as a command: from now on, the architect had to be concerned solely with the large-scale form of the structure, not with silly trivialities such as gargoyles and grillwork, no matter how much pleasure such things may have given viewers. It’s somewhat stunning just how uniform the rejection of “ornament” became. Since the eclipse of Art Deco at the end of the 1930s, the intricate designs that characterized centuries of building, across civilizations, from India to Persia to the Mayans, have vanished from architecture.

> Life was violent, discordant, and uninterpretable. Art should not aspire to futile goals like transcendence, but should try to express the often ugly, brutal, and difficult facts of human beings’ material existence. To call a building “ugly” was therefore no longer an insult: for one thing, the concept of ugliness had no meaning. But to the extent that it did, art could and should be ugly, because life is ugly, and the highest duty of art is to be honest about who we are rather than deluding us with comforting fables.

Quotes from a long really good (long) article on the issue: https://www.currentaffairs.org/2017/10/why-you-hate-contempo...

Re:The Rise of the Architectural Cult on Monday December 30, 2019 @07:11PM (#21917869)
Nassim Taleb also ranted regarding this:

> The problem is architects building structures to impress other architects --but plumbers don't act on impressing other plumbers.

> 2- Ancestral architecture: no Euclidian geometry, high dimensionality. Even pyramids when close show rich micro-patters (Met in NYC). Today's architecture is "smooth", Eucledian, & of low dimensionality.

https://twitter.com/nntaleb/status/1073918706663768065