News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

kfuwbi2640

Re:Everybody Can Make DeepFakes Now [video] on Tuesday March 31, 2020 @09:33AM (#22737352)
Apologies for a late response here (by HN standards where conversations last only a number of hours). I agree that an attacker could compromise weaker devices and sign their deep fakes with them. But then hopefully those keys Or that manufacturer would be blacklisted. In my mind, a company like Hauwei could implement this, but I as a consumer of media wouldn’t necessarily trust photos from their devices. But photos signed by an iPhone where Apple has a better privacy record, I could trust more.

Thanks for replying though, this does help me understand the challenges in a system like this.

Re:Everybody Can Make DeepFakes Now [video] on Saturday March 28, 2020 @11:07PM (#22716019)
I’ve seen a number of attempts to identify deepfakes and other forms of manipulated images using AI. This seems like a fool’s errand since it becomes a never ending adversarial AI arms race. Instead, I haven’t seen a proposal for a system I think could work well. Camera and phone manufacturers could have their devices cryptographically sign each photo or video taken. And that’s it. From that starting place, you can build a system on top of it to verify that the image on the site you’re reading is authentic. What am I missing that makes this an invalid approach? I do understand that this would require manufacturers to implement, but it seems achievable to get them onboard. I even think you get one company like Apple to do this and it’s enough traction for the rest of the industry to have to follow suit.
I’ve seen a number of attempts to identify deepfakes and other forms of manipulated images using AI. This seems like a fool’s errand since it becomes a never ending adversarial AI arms race.

Instead, I haven’t seen a proposal for a system I think could work well. Camera and phone manufacturers could have their devices cryptographically sign each photo or video taken. And that’s it. From that starting place, you can build a system on top of it to verify that the image on the site you’re reading is authentic. What am I missing that makes this an invalid approach?

I do understand that this would require manufacturers to implement, but it seems achievable to get them onboard. I even think you get one company like Apple to do this and it’s enough traction for the rest of the industry to have to follow suit.