News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

k5329

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @12:28PM (#13653661)
Oh one other thing:

>Faculty in fields like Biology and Physics are also overwhelmingly liberal, but departments generally know nothing about the political views of faculty candidates.

One of interesting thing to keep in mind, is that while it's true that biology and physics professors also lean liberal, the ratios are inline with what the ratios have historically been in academia as a whole. They are closer to 3:1 or 4:1. Fields like sociology or social psychology are closer to something like 20:1. A college student taking a sociology class is more likely to be taught by a Marxist than a Republican[0]!

(Please don't tell me that the intellectual underpinnings of marxism are more correct than that of conservatism. I'll have an aneurysm.)

[0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/08/opinion/sunday/a-confessi...

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' on Wednesday February 15, 2017 @12:24PM (#13653629)
> The median US Republican (good proxy for conservatism) does not believe in evolution or climate change- extremely difficult to find a serious faculty candidate who fits that profile, just for starters. Do you not agree with that?

The "median" person doesn't become a professor. I think you're confusing object level Republican issues with conservatism. One doesn't have to agree with the Republican party on every issue to be considered a "conservative." One thing that opened my eyes to this issue was reading Haidt's book "The Righteous Mind." Conservatism and liberalism are ways of looking at the world which involve valuing different moral principles.

From a book review[0] on the book:

"He and his colleagues have compiled a catalog of six fundamental ideas that commonly undergird moral systems: care, fairness, liberty, loyalty, authority and sanctity...

These moral systems aren’t ignorant or backward. Haidt argues that they’re common in history and across the globe because they fit human nature. He compares them to cuisines. We acquire morality the same way we acquire food preferences: we start with what we’re given. If it tastes good, we stick with it. If it doesn’t, we reject it. People accept God, authority and karma because these ideas suit their moral taste buds. Haidt points to research showing that people punish cheaters, accept many hierarchies and don’t support equal distribution of benefits when contributions are unequal.

You don’t have to go abroad to see these ideas. You can find them in the Republican Party. Social conservatives see welfare and feminism as threats to responsibility and family stability. The Tea Party hates redistribution because it interferes with letting people reap what they earn. Faith, patriotism, valor, chastity, law and order — these Republican themes touch all six moral foundations, whereas Democrats, in Haidt’s analysis, focus almost entirely on care and fighting oppression. This is Haidt’s startling message to the left: When it comes to morality, conservatives are more broad-minded than liberals. They serve a more varied diet."

These values are inherited culturally and some evidence[1] suggests there may be a genetic component too.

So, to clarify, I'm not necessarily asking that professors be hired with wrong object-level beliefs. But I do want to make sure that we're not discriminating against people who view the world through different moral structures, and who may view certain issues more clearly than those of us who are inclined to be on the left.

Have you ever considered that the reason for the intellectual bankruptcy (I note your mention of Glenn Beck et al) in the right in America today is because conservative minded people have been pushed out of academia (and the media, and entertainment...)? I can't emphasize this point enough, but the evidence is that there is overt and explicit discrimination against conservatives in academia. People with conservative beliefs are 100% correct to distrust these institutions, and our society, our democracy, and our political discourse as a whole is poorer for it.

> It seems like those in the field are usually the best at distinguishing crankery from genuine ideological difference- if we don't trust them, who do we trust?

One might also argue "we should trust tech interviewers to determine who's a good fit for tech and who's an imposter. And if that discriminates against people of color or women, that's just because they're worst."

My answer to that would be "humans are irrational, and we have to recognize the possibility of bias and therefore we need to think long and hard about how to ensure that everybody is getting a fair shot." The bare minimum we could do is make it absolutely clear that openly and explicitly discriminating against people (our fellow citizens!) based on their political beliefs is incredibly harmful and morally wrong.

[0]: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/25/books/review/the-righteous...

[1]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3092984/

(btw: Scott Alexander identifies as a liberal and votes for the Democratic Party)

Also, politicizing a scientific-existential threat is not unique to the right: http://www.vox.com/2016/10/18/13012394/i-732-carbon-tax-wash...

I would also be remiss to mention that Republican intellectuals just put forward a carbon tax proposal last week: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/08/opinion/a-conservative-ca...

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @07:36PM (#13648710)
>Honest question: does this also mean that Earth Science departments should go out of their way to hire climate change denialists, and Biology departments should go out of their way to hire creationists and anti-vaxxers?

Absolutely not.

>In my field (Biology) it seems like it'd be almost impossible to find a well-qualified faculty candidate who is an average US conservative without applying some truly outrageous "affirmative action" for conservatives.

Have you considered that your view of an "average" US conservative is incredibly biased by the media you consume and the environment you operate in? And that your incorrect stereotype might be the reason you seem comfortable making arguments against observed discrimination that you would immediately reject if they were applied to other groups?

In the current environment you operate in, would you even know if one of your peers is conservative? Is it safe for them to be "out" about their political beliefs?

> Also, have you considered that academics don't select for liberalism, but liberals select for academia?

I've considered it, but the evidence suggests that discrimination is a better explanation of the facts. Haidt notes that historically most university departments were not the political monocultures they are now. Haidt also responds directly to your criticisms about qualifications and personal preference. I quote:

On intelligence:

"[Are conservatives simply less intelligent than liberals, and less able to obtain PhDs and faculty positions?] The evidence does not support this view… [published studies are mixed. Part of the complexity is that…] Social conservatism correlates with lower cognitive ability test scores, but economic conservatism correlates with higher scores (Iyer, Koleva, Graham, Ditto, & Haidt, 2012; Kemmelmeier 2008). [Libertarians are the political group with the highest IQ, yet they are underrepresented in the social sciences other than economics]"

On self-selection:

"Self-selection clearly plays a role. But it would be ironic if an epistemic community resonated to empirical arguments that appear to exonerate the community of prejudice—when that same community roundly rejects those same arguments when invoked by other institutions to explain the under-representation of women or ethnic minorities (e.g., in STEM disciplines or other elite professions). [Note: we agree that self-selection is a big part of the explanation. If there were no discrimination and no hostile climate, the field would still lean left, as it used to. But it would still have some diversity, and would work much better.]"

Given that there's ample evidence of explicit evidence of discrimination against conservatives in academia, that is a straightforward explanation for the disparity we observe.

I'd highly recommend reading the three papers I've linked in this thread for an overview of this issue which goes deeper than the "conservatives don't want to be in academia and even if they did, they'd be too stupid to contribute anyways" idea.

>have you considered that there are certain truths in these fields that simply contradict the conservative worldview?

Have you considered that every ideological system has its own blindspots, and that the mechanisms of peer-review breakdown in an ideological mono-culture? Consider that some of the social scientific concepts facing the toughest scrutiny in the ongoing replication crisis are concepts beloved by a certain ideological group, like implicit bias and stereotype threat[0]? And that ideological blindspots can negatively affect the search for scientific truth, both by embedding values in the research that's conducted and by the absence of research in other directions? That these ideological blindspots might even exist in your own field of biology?

[0]: http://heterodoxacademy.org/2016/02/23/are-most-published-so...

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @06:12PM (#13648202)
> Heterodox Academy's stated mission is to advocate for more conservatives in academia.

Heterodox Academy advocates for ideological heterogeneity in departments, which in the context of the academy as it exists today means conservatives. It was created by Jonathan Haidt[0] who is not and has never been a conservative. Considering the results of the study, it would be impossible for any significant number of conservative social psychology professors to be a part of the organization (there are no significant numbers of conservative social psychology professors).

If you choose not to read the studies that I've cited, that's your own partisan anti-intellectualism and it's a perfect example of how partisanship (even left-wing partisanship) prevents the search for truth.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathan_Haidt

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:50PM (#13648050)
>I'm talking about conservative politicians - external actors, not internal.

Yes, I'm claiming (and evidence supports) that internal actors politicized these disciplines. Do some research into these fields. All of them were politicized in a remarkably short amount of time. Conservatives are just responding by denying public funding to self-identified partisan political activists.

> Also, I'd love to see some cites about the issue you raise from reliable sources.

I gave you cites from reliable sources. The second link I sent you is a review article of all of the research done into this subject. I'd highly recommend checking out some of the citations in that paper, they're very illuminating.

Another good one to check out is this paper[0] from Stanford which measured the implicit bias association test applied to political groups. In all of their studies (I believe they recreated 3) they found that implicit bias is as much as 50% stronger for political identity than it is for racial identity.

From that paper: "Compared with the most salient social divide in American society—race—partisanship elicits more extreme evaluations and behavioral responses to ingroups and outgroups. This remarkable patterns applies to both explicit and implicit measures of group affect and holds even when the tests of ingroup favoritism are unobtrusive and completely nonpolitical, and partisans are incentivized to treat copartisans no differently from opposing partisans."

[0] https://pcl.stanford.edu/research/2015/iyengar-ajps-group-po...

Re:'The Great Shame of Our Profession' on Tuesday February 14, 2017 @05:26PM (#13647848)
>Also note that conservative politicians in the U.S. are increasingly applying ideological pressure on academic research

Conservatives didn't politicize the academy alone. Studies[0] have shown left-wing professors will openly admit to discriminating against conservative peers and students. From the abstract I quote:

"In decisions ranging from paper reviews to hiring, many social and personality psychologists said that they would discriminate against openly conservative colleagues. The more liberal respondents were, the more they said they would discriminate."

Other studies[1] have confirmed that there is an incredible lack of political diversity in certain university departments and that it's likely caused by outright discrimination.

"This article reviews the available evidence and finds support for four claims: (1) Academic psychology once had considerable political diversity, but has lost nearly all of it in the last 50 years. (2) This lack of political diversity can undermine the validity of social psychological science via mechanisms such as the embedding of liberal values into research questions and methods, steering researchers away from important but politically unpalatable research topics, and producing conclusions that mischaracterize liberals and conservatives alike. (3) Increased political diversity would improve social psychological science by reducing the impact of bias mechanisms such as confirmation bias, and by empowering dissenting minorities to improve the quality of the majority’s thinking. (4)"

Given that these university departments are overtly discriminating based on political affiliation, is it any surprise to see funding for these university departments being politicized? Sorry, if you're discriminating based on political affiliation, you're not doing science, you're doing activism.

[0]: http://yoelinbar.net/papers/political_diversity.pdf

[1]: http://heterodoxacademy.org/2015/09/14/bbs-paper-on-lack-of-...