ispotato
ispotato on Hacker News
If a device is still pending approval by the RF spectrum regulator in a country, they're required to not use those channels by law. Software blocks mean that they can sell a device that's hardware capable before regulatory approval, and then unlock the functionality later. It allows them to ship the same hardware globally but comply with differing laws in different regions, and it's far from just google that does this. Every major wireless access point vendor, for example, will require you to identify the country in which you are operating and software lock which channels you are allowed to use, alongside other limitations like transmit power.
This is extremely common with smart TVs of all sorts, and smart devices in general. Every 5ghz-capable Roku device is in the same boat, for example.
The 5ghz spectrum in the US is broken up into UNII 1, 2, 2 Extended, and 3, which all have their own separate FCC regulations and certification process. Lazy manufacturers for these types of devices don't want to go through more than one process, especially for UNII 2 and 2-Extended channels, which have stricter requirements. So they just do the lower channels.
I can't say that I agree with Musk on much, but the DMCA is a plague on humanity. Especially with systems like YouTube's, which auto flags copyrighted content in videos with no consideration for if that content falls under fair use. The DMCA desperately needs revision, and I doubt we're ever going to see it, because anyone advocating for it is going to be portrayed as hating creators rather than hating badly written laws.
In the ISP world, copyright complaints are even more of a nightmare than social media, I feel like. Corporations will demand that the piracy is stopped, and there's no way to do that without strict monitoring and blocking of user traffic. Which is extremely intrusive from an ISP perspective, and goes against what you're supposed to be providing. At least with social media, the user is voluntarily making that activity publicly visible.