intelart
In the future they do.
do the same for services, infrastructure, etc. Remove the advertising component and put it back in your pocket. E.g. if a shoe had cost $50, now it costs $30 because you've removed the shoe company's adveritsing component. Same for every product. You're now 30k per year richer.
However, you are now underinformed. Now pay for some apps that you would have seen the advertising in, in order to inform you. You are now only 15K per year richer after that additional direct outlay.
However, this direct outlay is smaller than the indirect outlay had been, because you are not supporting ad agencies, marketing managers, sending your products' message to people wildly not in its market, and so forth. you are paying for apps which inform you directly.
In addition to the fact that you have "cut out the middleman" - all this friction of paying people to send out messages on your used products' behalf - you (and everyone) ALSO gets the benefit of not having this constant high noise floor, of having to see tampon ads when you're a guy, beard care when you're a lady, and so forth.
In other words, EVERYONE is better off. There really is no catch - just like there really is no catch that there is 0 advertising necessary to get people to know about municipal water works.
If everyone had to constantly see ads about the benefits of getting water from a tap, even the people who already had that, AND it cost you - and everyone - 40% more due to all the advertising...well, that benefits no one doesn't it? We really can live in a cheap and cool world which as as good with respect to advertising as our daily interaction with water works advertising is: none at all, and the product is cheap and works and everyone knows about it and has it.
welcome to the future.