illza
Spending years going to classes that do nothing but teach you things you have already mastered is not practice. It's torture. To improve retention and mastery you keep using the skills you've attained to greater effect. The compounding is what matters. Move too slowly and people shut down, tune out, and ignore the material. That's when material is forgotten.
When we're talking about a general rule for the masses, I don't think different cutoffs would be that helpful past 4-years old. It would be more beneficial to split them up and teach them differently. That said, it's far more important for parents to make these decisions for their own child. Sometimes they're ready, sometimes they aren't. But there's a lot of growth that can happen when we aren't quite ready for something or when we don't think they are. Everyone is far too afraid of failure, or barring failure, afraid of difficulty. Let them try. They might surprise you. If they struggle, help them along. The trouble is, there are a lot of kids who struggle and simply can't or won't get the help they need to grow through it.
I've definitely been happy with some of the concepts that are taught early (like 0) and not quite so happy with some others. But, I've mostly went into this with the expectation that I'll probably be solidifying concepts more than his teachers will. This is primarily due to my time with him being 1-on-1 and sometimes because I know him better and can speak his language easier.
Anecdotally, most of the pre-K programs around here (Indianapolis) teach toward Kindergarten preparedness, which is to say, they teach the alphabet and associated sounds and most of the digraphs and diphthongs as well, and for Mathematics generally counting as high as you can make it (most of ours target between 20 and 100), some simple single-digit addition, and shapes.
Kindergarten here focuses fairly heavily on reading. From sight-words to all-out phonics, reading is the primary objective. Kindergarten, however, is the year in school with the highest variance in ability between children, and as such can lead to very different perspectives. My oldest child is 6 years old and in 1st grade at the moment. He's a bit of an outlier though, so take anything I say with a grain of salt. He was easily ready for Kindergarten when he was 4. He has a March birthday though, so it would have taken quite some convincing to get the school to accept him early. His maturity level though, led us to keep him in pre-K and send him to Kindergarten on-time. Even so, he's essentially reading between a 4th and 5th grade level before he's even halfway through first grade. There are about 4-6 others in his school that are around the same level (99%ile on every test they're given). Others in his class have exactly the opposite situation. Some, are just not ready developmentally. Some simply aren't interested. Some kids have older siblings and are used to acting out to get any attention. Some of them didn't attend any pre-school at all. And some that didn't attend a pre-school receive zero help at home. My son's Kindergarten class (at the start of the year) had kids that ranged from having a 2nd-grade reading level to those that didn't know any of the letters of the alphabet. But they all generally are able to read around a 1st grade level by the end of the year. I have a profound respect for Kindergarten teachers after last year! Having a classroom of 20-30 kids of such widely varying abilities seems like a fairly impossible situation to me.
In any case, I can speak of my oldest son's experience a lot more than I can of anyone else. So, understand that what I say skews toward the high-ability scale. But I don't know of any Kindergarten classrooms that don't teach reading. I'd be curious to know where you went to school because that seems completely contrary to my experience. Our teachers sent home paper copies of stories for our children to read to us, and this started within the first month of Kindergarten. I'm sure the results were varied, but they taught it.
I went to Kindergarten in 1987 and they taught us how to read there as well. Some of us had a head start from what our parents taught us. Most of us didn't go to any sort of pre-school, and in general, all of us were 5 when we started. By the end of Kindergarten, everyone in my class could read around a first-grade level at minimum. We could do single and two-digit addition and subtraction and we were starting to work on memorizing the multiplication tables. We were taught some rudimentary music reading (notes on the treble and bass clefs) as well. Granted, this was an all-day Kindergarten at a private school (in Michigan) with a smallish class size (~22) but I didn't feel it was too atypical. It wasn't until I was in college that I learned that not all Kindergarten classes were full-day. And it wasn't until I had kids that I found out that a lot of things I learned in Kindergarten weren't "standard". But when I was kid, everyone could read by the time they were in 1st grade. Spelling and Vocabulary were all that was holding anyone back at that point.
There are benefits that can be obtained from playing games, video or otherwise. I, personally, have used pokemon to teach reading, story-telling, math, strategy, problem solving, and a myriad of other things to my oldest son. His brother isn't far behind him. We play minecraft, smash bros, mario kart; I even recently introduced him to portal 2. Some of what I let him do is for fun. Some is to gauge his interest in things. Other times I use the time to teach him something new. But the biggest factor of this strategy working is and will almost always be parental involvement.
Most of the backlash I see/hear/read about from other parents is due primarily to an unwillingness to get interested in what their children are interested in. They'll buy them the game and go enjoy some "peace and quiet" and never think twice about it. There's something to be said of a parent really taking an interest and learning about a new universe with their children. I'm far from perfect, but that's what I've been attempting, and it's working out pretty well so far.
There was a quote in an Orson Scott Card book, "The Lost Gate" where the main character speaks of his sort-of adopted mother/trainer/mentor where he mentions that "Love ... it's a term for the woman in my life who loves me enough to read the novels I'm reading just so she can try to figure out what they're teaching me."
TL;DR - Games aren't inherently good or bad. But it's up to the parent to actually do the parenting. They can't just throw a "good video game" in front of their children and expect them to magically grow into engineers or doctors.