News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

idontwantit

Re:Whose Land – Indigenous Nations of North America on Friday July 10, 2020 @02:53PM (#23794940)
The examples of early natives torturing an executing people is a strange choice here.

Readers, don't forget that these people are the contemporaries of the perpetrators of chattel slavery, and the french revolution, to name a few popular examples.

The sordid atrocities committed all around the Americas by indigenous Europeans are very well-documented and continued beyond the 18th century, legitimized by the US society and government.

To bring such a thing up in defense of borders created during and with the help of those same atrocities is disingenuous, to put it kindly.

It appears to me that such a defense is an attempt to compare 18th century natives to modern US citizens, an obviously unfair comparison, much the same as if I were to compare modern native Americans to Columbus or 18th century slave-owners in the south.

> How did you handle identifying yourself to the police?

I never had the opportunity to find out

> Also, was this when you could still get a greyhound bus ticket without photo ID?

No clue

> Where you ever asked for ID when cashing or writing a check?

I don't really remember, didn't have much opportunity to cash checks anyway

I think your objections are already addressed by the comment
Do you think the government as it is setup right now is highly responsive to the will of voters?

Do you think that adding non-citizen voters will change the answer to the above?

If non-citizen voters made the government more responsive to the will of voters, do you think the will of non-citizen residents is significantly different than the will of citizen residents? How is it different?

Do you think will be inundated by immigrants who want sharia law? Is that where you're going with this? Do you think there could be enough immigrants to enact such a thing? Do you think that's possible given the basic freedoms guaranteed by the constitution?

> When those problems manifest, we should deal with them

I think this is one of the key problems with a hyper-conservative government.

If your default position is "don't change it" on every issue, then you have a very difficult time solving problems.

More liberal governments that frequently change the rules are like startups vs very large corporations. They are more agile and better able to quickly deal with problems as they arise. They are "responsive" in a way conservative government is not.

Look at recent statewide rent control measures in California. There was a lot of hand-wringing about what it could mean in this scenario or that scenario, but in the end the response is

> When those problems manifest, we should deal with them

Which I think is the sentiment of a people who really feel like they have a handle on their government and that it responds to their will.

Voter ID laws are often used to disenfranchise poorer voters by creating bureaucracy mazes or DMV-like conditions to stop voters from acquiring the necessary credentials.

https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/chal...

Anecdotally, as someone who was living in poverty before I got into this line of work, I did not have a state-issued ID and did not have time to waste or even the inclination to get one (my state does not have voter id laws).

Sure many will go out of their way in order to acquire credentials, but much like email scams, the value of voter suppression is in the marginal success.

Lastly, the amount of real voter fraud (well below 10% last I checked) seems minimal vs the amount of people who don't have credentials (about 10% according to the above).

I will leave you with this quote:

"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer"

Isn't that the meaning of "justice"?