however
In that light, I'd like to see the numbers a different way. How about the difference in direct cash injections. I have no idea where to find it, but it might show a different story.
Also, when it comes to externalities that are hard to measure, isn't there a good chance that the enormous increases in human quality of life due to abundant and relatively cheap access to energy are greater than the costs generated by pollution.
"Oil, natural gas, and coal benefited most from percentage depletion allowances and other tax-based subsidies"
It seems disingenuous to directly compare taxing someone less than you theoretically could have vs the "direct federal expenditures" on renewable energy.
Also, "many of the 'subsidies' available to the oil and gas industries are general business opportunity credits, available to all US businesses"